This week on the podcast, Blaine gives an overview and welcome to all listeners (0:02) before inviting Adam and Donovan to discuss what they've done on the two week break (0:45). After that, Blaine explains in non-spoilers why 'Lucky' on Apple TV doesn't cut it for engaging viewing, but it may have a redeeming use (1:47). Also in non-spoilers, the hosts discuss their overall view of this season of 'House of the Dragon' (3:49) and the movie 'Warfare,' which is now streaming on HBO Max (8:04).
In spoilers, they discuss how 'House of the Dragon' is getting some major, but little, things right this season (11:51) as well as what makes 'Warfare' a crucial film (47:09).
For more, visit The Alabama Take site and sign up for the newsletter!
Hey, welcome to Taking it down, the TV and streaming podcast from the working class folk at the Alabama Take.
Speaker AWe come to you once a week with spoiler free section that begins the podcast that you can use as a recommendation guide and then with spoilers after a short break.
Speaker ASo you will not hear what could ruin the show for you.
Speaker ANot at the beginning.
Speaker AThis week, Adam Donovan and I are discussing House of the Dragon and its third season through episode five and the film Warfare, which is streaming on HBO Max as well.
Speaker ALet's get in the discussion and to do so, let me get Adam and Donovan into the show.
Speaker AAll right, we're all here.
Speaker AIt's me, it's Adam, it's Donovan.
Speaker AAnd we should look and sound really refreshed.
Speaker ATwo weeks off for a break.
Speaker AWe're back now in our weekly slot.
Speaker AIf you're not a follower, listener, subscriber, take a second press pause on this episode, go to the show in your app and hit the plus sign or follow sign or subscribe.
Speaker AAnd that way you can see us every Tuesday morning and you can make your decision on if the shows are right for you.
Speaker ABut we do start with non spoilers every week so you can listen to that part every week if you wanted.
Speaker ADoes anyone want to share what they did for summer break today?
Speaker BI found what was left of a squirrel in my backyard and I put it in my trash can.
Speaker AThat was my summer break rip.
Speaker BIt had clearly been there for a while.
Speaker AIt's probably what got into my H Vac system.
Speaker AYeah, when I went without air for about three or four days, we got.
Speaker CThat problem solved though.
Speaker AYeah, it's solved.
Speaker AShould be those not in Alabama, you know, that's rough stuff.
Speaker AWe'll get into some television then.
Speaker AIf you're expecting more from Lucky on Apple tv, maybe temper some expectations.
Speaker ALucky is a bit of a crime caper that stars Anya, Taylor, Joy, Annette, Benning and Timothy.
Speaker AAll of that.
Speaker AI wish I could say great things about it because it's.
Speaker AThat sounds kind of great, but I can't.
Speaker AI'll point out some good things about it.
Speaker AIt's a role that Oliphant can do in his sleep.
Speaker AHe's one of the few who actually clocks in for the work.
Speaker ANot to say that they're not doing good acting.
Speaker AIt's just he's really good.
Speaker AHe isn't front and center either.
Speaker AIt's a Anya Taylor Joy led series, but Offense seems to be the one that's doing really great acting that evokes actual responses from him.
Speaker AThe others are fine but he's excelling.
Speaker AI think he's excelling these days anyway.
Speaker AAnd I've mentioned to you both that the first episode was entertaining enough, albeit really heavy with tropes.
Speaker AYou know, sometimes there's just no way around those.
Speaker AHowever, the second episode had several too.
Speaker AI don't think it's doing a lot that's fresh, despite some of the stars involved.
Speaker AIt's not that you don't care about the characters that that is a good thing.
Speaker AYou kind of do.
Speaker ABut their situation is fairly banal.
Speaker AMakes you kind of shrug at it.
Speaker AIt's an okay show.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AGreat one.
Speaker AEpisodic.
Speaker AExcuse me, not episodic.
Speaker ASerialized television for laundry.
Speaker AI think it really fits that I. I watch SNL during laundry on.
Speaker AOn many Sundays.
Speaker AAnd this is a. I'm going to do some chores around the house.
Speaker AI need something on, or I like to have TV on.
Speaker AI think you could probably follow it pretty easily with that.
Speaker AIf you miss a scene or two, I don't think you're going to be ruined.
Speaker AI. I wish there was more.
Speaker AYou know, it seems like those are really big stars who could do great things with a good script, but the writing is just so.
Speaker BSo that's your opinion is in line with pretty much every other review I've seen of it too, where it's just pedestrian at best.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ABut for us as a group, we're going to talk about House of the Dragon.
Speaker ALongtime listeners know we don't spoil anything here.
Speaker AWe have a few episodes to talk about if we want to, in broad terms, so we can really focus on that most recent one was probably the most fresh in our minds.
Speaker ABut we also have that one Tumbleton before Unbounded Unbent from last week.
Speaker AThis series still shuts out the outside world for me.
Speaker AYou know, when I'm watching it, I want to watch it in one big long sitting.
Speaker AAnd I don't care what's going on anymore outside.
Speaker AThat's a step in the right direction to say that it's good.
Speaker AYou know, when it's on, I'm so lost in the production, you know, it just feels like you're there.
Speaker AIt's like a Star wars used to feel with its first three.
Speaker CIt.
Speaker AIt feels palpable.
Speaker BIt doesn't hurt that I've, I think at this point gotten.
Speaker BWe're really used to the actors too.
Speaker BSo to the point where it's like, okay, yeah, I know you.
Speaker BI know what you're doing.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd unless I'm missing something, I'm just off Base.
Speaker AI think the characters, reactions to their situations, as fantastical as the situation sometimes are, they feel emotionally relevant, emotionally real.
Speaker AI'm a pretty big fan of this season and I know that it's had some slower episodes, probably on purpose.
Speaker BI continue to be a really big fan of a role that I wasn't sure was proper, which is Matt Smith when it was first announced, which is Matt Smith as Damon because, you know, he's a detestable human being.
Speaker BLike, he's a really bad person.
Speaker ABut on the show.
Speaker BOn the show.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWell, Matt Smith too.
Speaker ANot Matt Smith.
Speaker AWe don't know him, but.
Speaker ABut he seems cool.
Speaker BSmith playing him, you just.
Speaker BYou kind of forget that he's actually that bad of a guy.
Speaker AYou know, you're like, has there ever been a role more suited for the term rascal?
Speaker BIt.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BYou really are like, murdered his wife.
Speaker BHe's such a scamp.
Speaker CI was waiting for Donovan to use the word scamp, honestly, and I was going to if he didn't.
Speaker BHe is a scamp.
Speaker BFlitting around on his dragon.
Speaker AYou're right.
Speaker AHe's nailing this role.
Speaker AHe.
Speaker AHe may have.
Speaker AHe may be stealing this season, but Emma Darcy's so good, too.
Speaker BI said that to Beth today about.
Speaker BAnd she's like, it's why he was so good as Prince Philip in the Crown.
Speaker BAnd I'm like, you know what?
Speaker BLike, yes, he's kind of irritating and petulant, but he's such a lovable little scamp that you're like, you.
Speaker BYou see why Elizabeth keeps him around.
Speaker CHe was good in that.
Speaker BHe was very good.
Speaker CI think the.
Speaker CThe easiest.
Speaker CAnd I hadn't forgotten about that role.
Speaker CBut, yeah, like, you obviously want to compare it to Dr. Who.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker CHe has played the complex character.
Speaker CI almost wonder if he's.
Speaker CI haven't read the source material, but is he too good?
Speaker CLike, am I rooting for him too much at this point in the show?
Speaker AI've worried about that.
Speaker CI mean, we get into spoilers.
Speaker CI think before I'll fully expand that.
Speaker CHe seems.
Speaker CHe seems to just be outpacing everybody else.
Speaker CAnd there's.
Speaker CThere's other good actors on the show, of course, but he's so good.
Speaker BHe's very good.
Speaker BHe really is.
Speaker BHe definitely.
Speaker BI mean, I'm just speculating about his career, but it's interesting how he's really taken roles that are very different from the Doctor, especially since he got the Doctor as.
Speaker BAs a fairly young role and was good at it.
Speaker BWas.
Speaker BWas good pretty much.
Speaker BIn everything he's ever been in, but has almost, it seemed almost kind of consciously not to want to go and repeat that again.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CBut these, these two, not that Philip is like this, I don't know, sociopathic dragon riding warrior, but a complex guy with a complex relationship to power.
Speaker CThat's a good call.
Speaker CBeth.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAs soon as she brought it up, I was like, I just haven't thought about that role in years.
Speaker BHe was fantastic.
Speaker BAnd I really, I do honestly wonder if somebody whoever was casting for Game of Thrones had had the crown in mind casting him for this role.
Speaker BI see the, I see the parallels.
Speaker CDo you think Netflix ever, in any meeting, floated the idea of there being a dragon in the crown?
Speaker AThey missed an opportunity.
Speaker BLook, they couldn't even put the fucking Suez crisis in the crown properly, much less a dragon.
Speaker CYeah, the dragons get viewers.
Speaker ABesides House of the Dragon, we're going to talk some about the Alex Garland and Ray Mendoza film Warfare, which is also streaming on HBO.
Speaker AMax.
Speaker AIt's the 2025 movie which stars Will Poulter, Cosmo Jarvis, Joseph Quinn, Michael Ganofini, Charles Melton and others.
Speaker AI'm forgetting they're a platoon of Navy SEALs who are involved in what becomes a pretty dangerous mission in Iraq, noted for being a film that only uses the soldiers accounts and recreating it for production.
Speaker ADonald the one thing I kept returning to when I watched this is how sad it is that every generation or more needs a good reminder of how devastating and scary war can be.
Speaker BYeah, yeah.
Speaker AYou know, this is the what's the Civil War book I'm blanking on.
Speaker CRed Badge of Courage.
Speaker AYeah, this is the Red Badge of Courage, except in Iraq.
Speaker BIt's pretty, it surprised me.
Speaker BI'll say more about why it surprised me in spoilers, but I'll, I'll agree with you.
Speaker BSimilarly, like, I think it works as a movie and it works as its project, but I'm also interested in what we as viewers take to it with our own feelings about that war.
Speaker BI was just reading a New York Times article with one of the reporters, went back to Afghan.
Speaker BHe'd been a, a sniper, Marine sniper in Afghanistan.
Speaker BHe said he knew he'd killed at least seven people and he was going back to Afghanistan to talk with the disguise who had been a Taliban commander.
Speaker BAnd they'd been fighting against each other.
Speaker BLike they realized, he realized that they'd been in the area.
Speaker BAnd one of the things the Taliban commander asked him about was why so many US Veterans struggle with suicide.
Speaker BThe things that this guy out of his own experience was saying it got to the point for many people where we couldn't figure out how what we were doing was making America any more safe for free, your home, and you deal with that for the rest of your life.
Speaker BSo that's.
Speaker BThat's kind of the interesting for me.
Speaker BInteresting baggage too.
Speaker BThere's almost like a double tragedy of these soldiers in incredible danger and at the same time being like, what's the.
Speaker BWhy are they in incredible danger?
Speaker BYou know, it's, it's.
Speaker BWithout being overtly political.
Speaker BI always think there's a political message in something like that.
Speaker BIf, even if the message is no more than consider what you are doing and consider what the human cost is when we commit soldiers to war or when we make war on others.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ADid you think it was good?
Speaker ADo you recommend it?
Speaker BI did.
Speaker BNot a spoiler.
Speaker BI loved the when it ends, it goes to black and then it hits into a low song.
Speaker BI love Low.
Speaker BIt was a great surprise for me, but I thought the movie itself was good.
Speaker BI would recommend it.
Speaker BI would recommend it while saying if you don't.
Speaker BIf you watch it and don't like it or aren't captivated by it, I understand that too, because I do think that it's so particular a movie that it's not universal.
Speaker BIt's not for everyone, probably.
Speaker AOh, I agree with that.
Speaker AI agree with all that.
Speaker AIn fact, I don't have much more to add, which in that case, let's just take our break and on the other side, we will get into spoilers for both House of the Dragon, a few episodes maybe, as well as the streaming movie Warfare.
Speaker ASocial media has made it nearly impossible for you to see all that you followed or liked, but that's not the case with Alabama Tate.
Speaker ANow you can subscribe to the newsletter, which you'll receive almost weekly and features a quirky story as well as a recap of all that's happened on the site and the podcast.
Speaker AWhile you wait for today's podcast episode of Taking it down to return, hit up the show notes and subscribe to the newsletter.
Speaker AOkay, we're back from break.
Speaker AWe will begin the spoiler section with a customary trip to Westeros on our Dragons House of the Dragons fifth season.
Speaker AMainly, we'll bring up things from Unbent and Unbroken, that fifth episode, but just know there's a couple of episodes we could very well spoil, such as the one before at Tumbleton might kind of bleed into this discussion.
Speaker ABefore we begin with Unbent and Unbroken, do you have Any lingering thoughts on Tumbleton?
Speaker ASo since we missed a couple weeks here, I think the only two threads that do not pick up in Unbent and Unbroken, that don't just follow through is that Ulf is telegraphing his death.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker AHe's.
Speaker AHe's coming in there and going.
Speaker AYou know that.
Speaker AProtesting.
Speaker AYeah, I'm doing a horrible off, but that's what he said.
Speaker ADamon brings in a sheep herder's head instead of his daughter Bayless for riding sheep stealer.
Speaker AThat doesn't really pick up in the.
Speaker AYou know, Unbent and Unbroken.
Speaker AThose are just about the only two.
Speaker BI'm not sure if it was supposed to be funny.
Speaker BI don't think it was.
Speaker BWe're like, where Damon is.
Speaker BIs arguing with Bela and then all of a sudden, like, you kind of see, like, the sheep, like, the shepherd down there.
Speaker BIt's like, that guy was instantly dead.
Speaker AI'm such a dunce.
Speaker AI was thinking, why does he look down there that.
Speaker AWho is that guy?
Speaker ASee another king.
Speaker BIt made me laugh because I'm like, yep, Damon.
Speaker BDamon is who he is.
Speaker AI.
Speaker BThe only thing I'll say about Tumbleton, beyond plot is that I'm really enjoying James Norton as Ormond.
Speaker BI just love what.
Speaker BI don't know.
Speaker BI'm loving what he's doing.
Speaker BI've seen him in other things and I like him.
Speaker BSo it was exciting to see him here and, like, he's clearly reveling being the villainous.
Speaker AWhat is he.
Speaker AWhat's he been in?
Speaker ABecause I've seen him.
Speaker BI swear he's been in all sorts of things.
Speaker BHe was even in, like, a mystery where he played.
Speaker BWhat was that called?
Speaker BHe played a vicar who solves mysteries.
Speaker BIt was on pbs, of course.
Speaker BSidney Chandler.
Speaker BThat's what it was.
Speaker AOh, cool.
Speaker AYou talking about funny?
Speaker AThe two things that I mentioned were both a little bit funny.
Speaker AUlf coming in and going, hey, I got some buds down at the bar.
Speaker AYou mind letting them off?
Speaker ACan they just not pay their taxes this week?
Speaker AOr whatever he was asking.
Speaker AThat's pretty funny shit.
Speaker BOlf is hilarious.
Speaker AHe's like a.
Speaker AHe's like Norm from Cheers coming up to the queen.
Speaker BI think, like, the premise for him is, like, what if just like an average schmuck got everything that he got and was just like.
Speaker CAnd absolutely failed to rise to the occasion.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AIt is a pretty much.
Speaker AIf the show were from his point of view, it would be a comedy.
Speaker ABesides Oldtown, who almost rule themselves.
Speaker AWe get some information on Dorne, they aren't Part of the kingdom.
Speaker AUh, what else does this title allude to for you?
Speaker AIt's called Unbent and Unbroken.
Speaker AAm I getting that right?
Speaker AUnbent and Unbroken.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ABecause there's like a third term.
Speaker ASometimes they'll throw in there unbowed.
Speaker AUnbent and Unbroken.
Speaker BFor me.
Speaker BThat title does not bode well for Sir Criston.
Speaker BBased on what we saw at the end as he gives a browsing speech about the Seven.
Speaker BThat was my other thought.
Speaker BIs that it refers to Sir Criston or at least how he thinks of himself.
Speaker CI was gonna.
Speaker CThe distance between how he thinks of himself and the reality that has played out.
Speaker CYou're talking about people telegraphing things.
Speaker CHim saying I'm the greatest warrior in the.
Speaker CAs he leads a failed guerrilla warfare antagonistic campaign.
Speaker CThey can't even cross a river.
Speaker BI mean, I assume we're supposed to think this, but it's like they get to that point, like, they have, like, no provisions or anything.
Speaker BLike, Kristen.
Speaker BBased on his actions of what he wants to do is stopping any chance of this being a useful force.
Speaker BRight?
Speaker BLike, men need food to fight, you know, like, they need food to march.
Speaker BThey don't have anything.
Speaker CAnother one guy just dropping in the field, in the marsh.
Speaker CLeave him.
Speaker CEverybody else looked pretty healthy at that point.
Speaker CFor one guy just to fall out.
Speaker AIt could have been dysentery.
Speaker CCould have been.
Speaker CYou'll get that.
Speaker CI mean, I guess they have horse meat now, at least.
Speaker BThat's true.
Speaker ADonovan.
Speaker AYou're right about that.
Speaker AThe men have to eat.
Speaker AIt's very similar to the argument Damon was making was, you got to pay these guys.
Speaker AYeah, you gotta pay these Guardsmen or they're not gonna guard anything.
Speaker BIt's not even that novel at this point.
Speaker BBut I do kind of like.
Speaker BIt helps keep me more in the world where it's like, okay, yes, these are guys that, like, fly around on fantastic dragons, but, like, people still need to eat, right?
Speaker BLike, there's still political consequences for things they do.
Speaker BLike, dragons can't really take and hold territory.
Speaker BYou need armies to do that.
Speaker BSo it kind of adds this other layer of, like, instead of them just being superheroes, like, the complications kind of make it interesting for me at least.
Speaker BTargaryen dragons are basically a metaphor for US Policy in Vietnam under Kissinger and Nixon when they increased bombings to try and get the North Korean or the North Vietnamese to the negotiating table without committing troops.
Speaker BThat is why I am declaring Tumble Town the new Hanoi,.
Speaker ABecause they're not gonna bomb it.
Speaker BIt's not gonna work.
Speaker BThey gotta send in ground troops.
Speaker AThat's a big deal.
Speaker AUnbent and unbroken reminded us all of Christian Coal, of course, a lot of telegraphing of who's gonna die.
Speaker ABut I think the interesting thing that they're doing is going and giving us that, but we don't know the win by whose hand.
Speaker AHow.
Speaker AHow's Christian Cole going to die?
Speaker AIs Damon going to catch him?
Speaker AIs.
Speaker AIs it going to be at a battle in Tumbleton?
Speaker AWill he ever make it to Tumbledown?
Speaker AI think that happens a lot here.
Speaker ADamon.
Speaker AI mean, he pretty much has predicted his own death, saw it, or thinks he's going to die at Harrenhal.
Speaker AWell, who's there?
Speaker AA were thinking there's gotta be a battle between the two.
Speaker AIs that what's going to happen?
Speaker AThat kind of thing is a nugget enough to keep me interested without spoiling anything, you know, without just beating you over the head too much with it.
Speaker COne thing with Cole that I think is paying off now is they used him to really show the horror of the dragons.
Speaker CEarly on, I thought, like, when you saw them in both the original series and now this, there's that moment where, like, the dragons enter the battlefield and it's like it is their nuclear weapon going off and everything that you thought you've understood so far.
Speaker CHe's been a jaded, broken guy since then.
Speaker CHe's a different man.
Speaker CAnd the payoff of having him.
Speaker CThis feels very earned to me that he hasn't really been in this season a whole lot.
Speaker CAnd now you can kind of laugh at him at the end of this episode.
Speaker CSaying, well, to die was actually the whole point.
Speaker CThat's why I made all these blunders.
Speaker CBut if you just think this is a man broken to nihilism, then everything he does kind of makes sense.
Speaker CAnd that's a.
Speaker CThat's a good reaction to the situation.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BThat he's been marked ever since that.
Speaker BI was basically.
Speaker BWhat Adam said is exactly what I was thinking.
Speaker BLike, it is.
Speaker BIt feels like a big payoff.
Speaker BFrom season two or from season two onwards, really good.
Speaker CThere are moments where, you know, we had an episode where Rhaenyra is basically just like, having to.
Speaker CThe whole episode was like, oh, holding the crown is tougher than taking it.
Speaker CBut from, like, a bureaucratic standpoint, I was like, oh, my God, this is like watching paint dry.
Speaker CThis is terrible.
Speaker CI wasn't into that.
Speaker CSo there are.
Speaker ADo you mean this season's episode?
Speaker CYeah, I was.
Speaker CI've never been more bored by an episode of Game of Thrones.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AYou talking about the one where she's having to deal with everybody's request and on top of like having her period and having to deal with surprises here and there is that episode.
Speaker CYeah, I did.
Speaker CI thought that that was so heavy handed in what it was trying to say that it was just like it's both boring and not very strong writing.
Speaker CBut.
Speaker CAnd there are moments where I think that they bring fairly modern concerns to say, like the small council meetings and they're like, well, you know the argument this time of like there's the out of touch guy talking about, oh, flea bottom, you know, whatever.
Speaker CAnd then you have other people arguing essentially for taking care of the people versus putting out a show of force.
Speaker CBut it's like, okay, whatever.
Speaker CBut the Cole's reaction to a nuclear bomb going off, that to me feels like very earned modern day intrusion, if that makes sense.
Speaker CWhereas some of these other ones, I'm kind of like, oh, okay, we get it.
Speaker AYeah, I can see that.
Speaker CIt's more of a make you feel don't make you think.
Speaker CTrying to think of the.
Speaker CWhat's the robot devil in Futurama?
Speaker CHe's like, your characters can't just say what they feel.
Speaker CThat makes me feel angry.
Speaker AUnbent and Unbroken also reminds me of Ormond.
Speaker AHe's from Old Town, the town that really doesn't.
Speaker AThey kind of govern themselves anyway.
Speaker ABut he's also in control of.
Speaker AOf this king whom he claims to serve in Darien.
Speaker ABut he's very much in control of him.
Speaker AHe's not bending to this guy.
Speaker AIt's Jason Norton playing Ormond.
Speaker AAnd I thought that was well done.
Speaker ATo show he.
Speaker AHe has this very similar smirk that Damon has, but his smirk is more of, I've got a king, but I.
Speaker ABut I'm really in control.
Speaker BOh, the kid is playing.
Speaker BDoing a good job of playing as being terrified of Ormond.
Speaker AOh yeah.
Speaker AAnd I would be too.
Speaker BSo there's such.
Speaker BThere's such a hint of menace underneath it all.
Speaker BYou like every.
Speaker BIt hasn't gone poorly so far, but every interaction you're just like, is he gonna snap?
Speaker BYou know, like, yeah.
Speaker COh, he.
Speaker CHe loses at the chess game or whatever they're playing and yeah, yeah.
Speaker CThat.
Speaker CThe tension again, that felt like very deserved.
Speaker CYou're like, this.
Speaker CThis dude's gonna do anything.
Speaker AYeah, don't apologize for winning.
Speaker AHe tells him.
Speaker CYeah, like you see flashes of like Theon and Reek in a way.
Speaker CLike obviously it hasn't been taken to that point.
Speaker CBut just the.
Speaker CThe control and like terror from one.
Speaker BLike both times, right.
Speaker BLike he's afraid in this episode he calls the.
Speaker BBasically the history's boring.
Speaker BAnd then he quickly marches it back when.
Speaker BWhen Ormond says with one like just says dry.
Speaker BAnd he has to take it.
Speaker BThat's how scared this kid is.
Speaker ATalk about some of those out in the field people with the Riverland and Northman, you know, they're the ones encountering the burned bridges.
Speaker ALiterally burn bridges.
Speaker ABut it does give us another quick opportunity to see the River Kid, as I've been calling him mentally.
Speaker AIt's Lord Tolly.
Speaker AI know, but I just keep thinking River Kid, you know, he's matured well beyond his years, would imply.
Speaker AI think it too hints that the Northmen are a lot more savage than anyone south.
Speaker ATheir leader almost begs to go headhunting again.
Speaker AAnd I like how they're being painted as you don't fuck with the Northmen.
Speaker AThey're kind of scary.
Speaker AThey're wild.
Speaker BThings are tough in the North.
Speaker BThis is something.
Speaker BThis is a complete sidebar, but it's sort of maybe not interesting, but I was thinking about how the whole like seasons last years and years and years thing is really not a part of this show so far.
Speaker BAnd it was thing I had liked in the original books because it's like an additional explanation of like why Civil War is so horrible.
Speaker BBecause, like, not only are you destroying each other, you're destroying the realm.
Speaker BAnd if you have a 20 year winner, you're done for.
Speaker BBut I think we had kind of with these Northmen, like the.
Speaker BIf we.
Speaker BFor.
Speaker BFor those of us who kind of remember or know about stuff outside of the show, it's like, oh, it might already be winter where they're from.
Speaker BLike, it's tough.
Speaker AOh, wow.
Speaker AI haven't thought about that.
Speaker AThat's a good point.
Speaker ASo with Cole's existential.
Speaker AHe's basically a death wish at this point, I think with his attack on the Riverland men, the Northman, did you see him as villain, hero, something else now in the game, does he seem more relatable now?
Speaker BI was gonna say Larys had a speech about whinging that he gave to Aemond, that Ser Criston might have stood to her here as well.
Speaker BNot really.
Speaker CBut yeah, he still comes across as a pretty giant prick, you know, like.
Speaker AOkay, yeah, I thought so too.
Speaker CYou're not rooting for him, but you maybe understand him a little bit more.
Speaker BI agreed and I feel like I agree with that, Adam and I think like they have done a good job of like, I don't necessarily like him.
Speaker BI think I understand where he's coming from.
Speaker BAnd I.
Speaker BBut I also think there's a.
Speaker BThere's a deep selfishness in him in the sense of the like, okay, you're going to get yourself killed, but you're getting all of these other people killed too.
Speaker CSure.
Speaker BThey don't exist for him outside of like an extension of his own whatever, right?
Speaker CThat, that moment where he's like, I've only ever served wealthy people, you know, essentially.
Speaker CAnd like you, you are offering me the same thing.
Speaker CBut, like, you know, there's a.
Speaker CThere's a path away from that where even if that path is violent, you're kind of like, yeah, yeah, get yours.
Speaker CThat kind of thing.
Speaker CBut he still is just like in that selfishness, kind of dragging everybody down with him.
Speaker CAnd like, for what purpose?
Speaker CWhich makes for great tv because the nihilism taking over is having one pocket of that is.
Speaker CThat's not bad viewing.
Speaker BIt makes stuff like Allison's brother splitting off of him.
Speaker BLike, yes, this does make sense.
Speaker BLike, he is like, you should be leaving this guy.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BHe wants to throw his life away, right?
Speaker ASir Gawain gives him the old, hey, I'm calling from Kentucky.
Speaker AI know you're the coach at Arkansas, but would you, you want to come on in?
Speaker ASir Cole's like, I done that.
Speaker ACome on.
Speaker AIt's a lateral move.
Speaker AI think the creators learned a lesson from last season where they showed us all of Aemond's nightmares.
Speaker AExcuse me, Daemon's nightmares.
Speaker ABut this season we get none of Aemond's.
Speaker AWe just see him waking up with the fever sweats.
Speaker AThose trips took up a lot of last season with Damon.
Speaker CI thought that was hilarious.
Speaker CLast season I thought it was great that people complained about it.
Speaker CI was, I was here for it.
Speaker AI mean, I didn't mind, honestly.
Speaker AThere's not a lot this show does that I really just am a stickler or pissed off about.
Speaker AI've just enjoyed it.
Speaker AI like being in the world, say,.
Speaker BWatching Aon and Harrenhal and thinking of some of the themes there.
Speaker BAnd, you know, Aegon brings them up too.
Speaker BI'm like, how have we gone this whole time without referring to this show as Operation Hot Mother?
Speaker AAlice is the stand in for Hot Mother here for Eamon.
Speaker AHe.
Speaker AShe's becoming the mom he wanted before leaving for Harren Hall.
Speaker AAnd it certainly implies he's going to do her bidding.
Speaker AUnless, well, I say, whereas Uncle Damon gave her the short shrift kind of poo pooed on her a little there.
Speaker AI'm not really going to give you hair and hall.
Speaker ACome on.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAlice is pissed.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AAnd she's going to use aan as much as she can.
Speaker AI'm going to tell you guys.
Speaker ARoywood Jr. Has been one of the smartest, if not the best maesters in any of these shows.
Speaker AWe've seen the three, but no, the maester who works at King's Landing, he's risking his neck for both sides and seems to be improving both sides a little every time he gets involved.
Speaker AMake him hand.
Speaker AI know he's maester.
Speaker AYou can't probably make him hand to the King of the Queen.
Speaker ABut yeah, he's the smartest of the bunch.
Speaker CThere is a continuing theme around the King's Landing stuff that's good.
Speaker CWhere you have opposing forces that realize they can't fully destroy each other in the current moment.
Speaker CAnd like, it's good.
Speaker CIt's good for everybody.
Speaker CAnd they even gesture to the other side and speak about them in private.
Speaker CLike this week it was the former queen saying there is good.
Speaker CYou know, there is good on the other side.
Speaker CThere is, but the.
Speaker CThe crown is going to crush kind of thing.
Speaker CAnd so they're all kind of.
Speaker CThere's very few characters in King's Landing completely sold out for their side.
Speaker ABy the way, the new lady on the council is a lady from House Frey.
Speaker AThey mention it briefly.
Speaker AYou gotta catch it.
Speaker AThat's notably Walder Frey's ancestor, I suppose if you remember him.
Speaker CShe's the one that has the great line, right?
Speaker CIs it always like this?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AWell, she needs some catching up from the new Master of Coin.
Speaker AYou know that guy they may as well be texting during Rhaenyra's staff meeting.
Speaker BThat made me laugh.
Speaker BThat rude like that, that.
Speaker BThat really made me laugh.
Speaker AThey flat out call Messeria the within feet of the woman.
Speaker AYeah, it reminds.
Speaker AReminds me of the story I told you, Donovan, that man is a son of a bitch.
Speaker AYou know, just putting your hand up doesn't mean you didn't say it.
Speaker AThe look that Matt Smith gives them here to to STFU was I thought good stuff from Matt Smith.
Speaker AJust doing acting without speaking.
Speaker ALove it.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker AAnd then of course he does basically tell him to shut up.
Speaker AIt's also why he's so good.
Speaker AAnd while have such deep heartbreak when Eamon kills him, I'm guessing if he.
Speaker BGoes, I'm not ready for him to go.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BHe's been a he's a.
Speaker BHe's a load bearing part of this show for me.
Speaker AAgreed.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd kind of what we alluded to at the beginning of like, is he too good at this role for the context of this narrative?
Speaker CBecause he's right a lot of the time, you know, and like, he is charismatic.
Speaker CLike when they're like, oh, a little speech to the city watch isn't going to help.
Speaker CAnd then he goes and he gives a speech and completely saves the day.
Speaker COr he's right in most of his council to Rhaenyra, he's the badass who shows up.
Speaker CI mean, him cutting through everybody going through to take King's Landing is like, how can you not root for this guy?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYou know, he's a liar anyway.
Speaker AWhy not just have him at least pretend to listen to his wife and be like, yep, gonna do that and then not go do it.
Speaker AThe smart guy would say, got it, wife, you're the queen.
Speaker AAnd then just go give the speech anyway.
Speaker CI mean, it's just part of his makeup, right?
Speaker CTo just be like, well, I'm, I'm not, you know, the old.
Speaker CLike when they go to Tracy on 30 Rock and give him all this stuff and he goes, I'm not gonna do any of that.
Speaker AWhat a good analogy.
Speaker CYou gotta lay it out there.
Speaker CAnd you know, I think another redeeming thing about him beyond Matt Smith's great acting is he through his visions and conversations with his brother, all this stuff, he is, I think, a true believer in like the end game of Fire and Ice.
Speaker CAnd like, he understands that the best thing he can do, like, yes, he wants his family in a position of power, but like, he's trying to move the pieces around the chessboard so that there's only one thing that matters in the end.
Speaker AYeah, he's bought in.
Speaker AYeah, I think that's.
Speaker AThat's been made very well apparent that.
Speaker BThat's how it seemed to me too.
Speaker BLike this felt like, why to your point, Blaine, about why doesn't he just lie?
Speaker BBecause it does feel like he's like, okay, he's a tr.
Speaker BBeliever.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BAnd he has, because of that, like, pledged his loyalty to Renera.
Speaker BBut he's also like, because of who he is, he's like, well, I'm going to serve you, of course, but I'm going to serve you by looking out for your best interests, even if you don't understand what your best interests are,.
Speaker CYou know, But I'm willing to believe him as like a big picture guy,.
Speaker BYou know, oh, me too.
Speaker BI. I think.
Speaker BAnd I think that like, that's the reason that he's like, I'm serving you even if you don't know what your best interests are.
Speaker BBecause he is that big picture guy.
Speaker BBecause he's got the.
Speaker BAnd honestly, just because he is who he is.
Speaker BYou know, he's not a humble.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AI want to ask you all about Mysaria, whom I mentioned briefly.
Speaker AYou know, here she goes to Alicent.
Speaker AShe doesn't believe that it's her that's really drinking the medicine for herself.
Speaker AIs he on Alicent's side?
Speaker AIs she seeing both sides?
Speaker AIs she playing both sides is probably the best way to ask this question.
Speaker AYou know, she doesn't tell on them when they try to escape as maids later in the episode, though we may not see her immediately go tell.
Speaker AWhat do you think about her?
Speaker AHow are we supposed to take her?
Speaker BI think we've got to let it play out some more is how I think we're supposed to take her.
Speaker BI think with like.
Speaker BI think it would almost be too easy to.
Speaker BWe'll see how it depends.
Speaker BI think it's almost too easy to believe that, like, if she's as experienced as she is, it's a little too easy that she.
Speaker BTo believe that she's like swayed by Alicent being like, you know, don't tell on us and you'll have favor with the Hightowers.
Speaker BYou have to think that, like, she's a little bit further down the road in the game than that.
Speaker BYou know, Master of Whispers, that's a pretty tricky position.
Speaker BYou kind of end up being on nobody's side.
Speaker AShe gets that from Alicent.
Speaker AAlicent also mentions the indignities women must endure in this land of Westeros.
Speaker AIt's much like ours.
Speaker ASadly, that theme is almost a part of every scene Rhaenyra is involved in where she's trying to lead or even have a council meeting.
Speaker AAnd it almost seems like a pretty decent course correction for the show.
Speaker AMain Game of Thrones when it existed,.
Speaker BSome people did not.
Speaker BAnd I think George R.R.
Speaker BMartin himself.
Speaker BI might be slandering the man, but I know he's not happy with this adaptation, but I loved it kind of focusing in.
Speaker BYes, it's the two families, but it is the two queens in many ways.
Speaker BAnd they're both in different positions and they both have different kinds of power, but they're also like butting up against similar things and the fact that they're both queens, they're both mothers, but they're one, you know, One has a dragon and the other has.
Speaker BWell, you know, Matt Smith or Damon says.
Speaker BYou know, he says.
Speaker BI think Allison is a born conspirator.
Speaker BYou know,.
Speaker CShe's good at it.
Speaker CAnd I think that everybody that in interacts with her.
Speaker CI don't know if they tell the actors this, but they always read as like being impressed by her, like her ability to wield essentially no power into getting what she wants, which for most of the season has been just trying to like smooth the waters for the people directly around her.
Speaker CSo it's.
Speaker CIt's kind of like, how can you.
Speaker CShe's not really antagonistic.
Speaker CYou know what I mean?
Speaker BYeah, it's different.
Speaker BIt's different now because she's not, for example, she's trying to get out.
Speaker BIt seems like her plan right now is to get out with what she believes may be her only surviving child.
Speaker BShe's not even looking ahead to like link up with Ormund or anything.
Speaker BShe's just like get.
Speaker BOr her only surviving child in King's Landing is what I should say.
Speaker AWell, as far as she knows it is.
Speaker BYeah, well, they.
Speaker BThat's true because she doesn't act.
Speaker BShe doesn't know actually what's happened to her ward yet or to her son who is Ormond's ward.
Speaker BI suppose we do with the viewer.
Speaker BThat's a good point, Blaine.
Speaker ANot worth analysis, but there's a new Joffrey on the scene.
Speaker AHe comes to Rhaenyra, you know, she's asked for her son, Joffrey, who would be king if anything happens to her.
Speaker AHe's the last.
Speaker AIs he the last one left for her?
Speaker BIf I think there are there not, I say, aren't there two younger ones, maybe one of them a boy that are hers and Damon's son.
Speaker BBut I think Joffrey is the last of the.
Speaker BOf the sons that she had with her.
Speaker BI can't remember his name, but her.
Speaker ALover, well, he was a strong.
Speaker BIf I remember correctly.
Speaker BYeah, you know, the brown hair.
Speaker BI think the two with Damon are both golden haired, if I remember.
Speaker BAnd I think they're in supposed to be across the sea right now with where B was supposed to go.
Speaker AOrmond proves to be an.
Speaker ABut he's also brilliant, you know, hiring flea bottom folk to kill Ra's watchmen or guards who, oh, by the way are working for free.
Speaker AThat's a smart piece of strategy.
Speaker AHe probably doesn't know they're working for free.
Speaker ABut still to employ that, it's hard to trace back to him though.
Speaker AThey do I mean, I say it's hard, it's not incredibly hard, but still, he could.
Speaker AThere's some plausible deniability, maybe.
Speaker AAnd that's not to mention holding up in a town that she wouldn't dare firebomb.
Speaker AShe's gonna have to send in the ground troops, as you mentioned, as the comparison to Vietnam.
Speaker AAnd, you know, try to spare Darien, who's her son, or, excuse me, who's the ward.
Speaker AI don't know if she'll want to spare him so that she can kill him in front of people.
Speaker AI don't know what she would want to do there, but it's basically all me saying.
Speaker AAnd Ormond's very smart.
Speaker BOrmond's read the histories.
Speaker AYeah, exactly.
Speaker AHe's a.
Speaker AHe's got a flavor for the history and also has a penchant for hating smells.
Speaker ANot sure how that could even play.
Speaker BThat's Chekhov's smelly gun.
Speaker AChekhov's cologne here.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd you know, speaking of Borman, great to have him tell the story of Mera Martell and how Doran doesn't bend the knee to the kingdom and he doesn't answer young Darion if Mera is a hero or villain.
Speaker AI found that kind of interesting.
Speaker AMara fought off the Targaryens and basically made Dorne a self governing place up and through Game of Thrones.
Speaker ASpeaking of telegraphing things, things that are definitely going to happen, Adam of Hull definitely hits on Baela.
Speaker AGot a little sweet spot for Baela already when he tells her if she gets married, we'll fly away in exile.
Speaker AAnd she likes that.
Speaker CBut first they just got to get a little food.
Speaker ABut let's get you a little food, sweetie.
Speaker CAnd then off they went.
Speaker CA nice little date that's.
Speaker APut a pin in that.
Speaker AWe'll watch that.
Speaker BIt must be awesome to have so many hot relatives like you.
Speaker BJust go from hot cousin to hot cousin.
Speaker CNo one's touching that, Donovan.
Speaker AWe're already an Alabama podcast.
Speaker AI mean, come on.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BHe's her uncle.
Speaker BRight?
Speaker BBecause she's Damon's daughter.
Speaker BSo she's the granddaughter of the sea snake.
Speaker BHe's the sea snake son.
Speaker AShe.
Speaker AShe would be her.
Speaker BHe.
Speaker BHe would be her uncle, I believe.
Speaker BKeeping it in.
Speaker BKeeping it in the family.
Speaker CSylvia style.
Speaker CFelt bored to understand how everyone's related in the show at this point.
Speaker BTake it from me, if they're mackin, they're related.
Speaker AGood one.
Speaker AMy second favorite actor in this series is Tom Glenn Carney, who plays Aegon.
Speaker BHe's actually doing A good job.
Speaker AI think he's killing it, man.
Speaker AHe.
Speaker AHe torments Eamon, but he doesn't know that he is, you know, from afar.
Speaker AHe doesn't even know much about what's going on with Eamon.
Speaker AAnd then Eamon torments Aegon and they're both playing head games with one another without even being in each other's presence.
Speaker AI loved that.
Speaker BWell, I love the mother theme too, where both of them believe that the other is their mother's favorite.
Speaker AThat's.
Speaker BBoth of them sincerely believe that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AOne of the more elevated performances, I think, is what he's doing.
Speaker AHe.
Speaker AHe adds, there's this scene where he's sitting there and Larys is about to chew him out, but he hasn't quite done it yet.
Speaker AAnd he's got this bouncing leg of impatience and the shortened breaths of surprise and anger.
Speaker AWhen Larry does dress him down.
Speaker AWatch.
Speaker AIf you want to watch that scene again, watch how short his breaths get.
Speaker AIt's like he said, you.
Speaker AHow dare you.
Speaker ABut he can't, right?
Speaker ABecause Larry says.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AIt makes him murdering his murdering of the boot man, the bootlicker man.
Speaker AIt made it all that more satisfying to me to watch later.
Speaker AIt's a classic Game of Thrones maneuver where they give you someone who.
Speaker AWhom you don't like.
Speaker AYou don't like them for a while.
Speaker AThey're a character, and then they put them on the down and outs and then you're.
Speaker AYou're having so much more fun with them or you're.
Speaker AYou're at least kind of rooting for them, you know, he's basically a flea bottom character at this point.
Speaker AAnd it makes me think that I wish he and Ulf could just hang out once.
Speaker AThey both love to drink and rebel.
Speaker CI mean, Larys also being shown to have like some sort of backbone or moral compass to be like, not only even worse than, like, you were a bad king, you're just a.
Speaker CYou're a bad person.
Speaker CAnd like, after listing out all the reasons why that was great.
Speaker CAnd his.
Speaker CYou talk about watching scenes again for maybe what wasn't obvious as the dude is still being stabbed on the ground.
Speaker CYou just see Larys in the background.
Speaker AGo, yeah, it was comedic.
Speaker CNow I gotta undo this or cover it, whatever, you know, he's created work for me.
Speaker BHe is so.
Speaker BI cannot remember the name of that actor, but I love the guy playing Laris.
Speaker BHe's consistently.
Speaker BI don't know, fun is the word, but Matthew Needham.
Speaker BSorry, I was just looking him up consistently, just like a Captivating character in whatever scene he's in.
Speaker BLike he's kind of funny and dry and droll but also like, you know, he's been set up enough that it's like that.
Speaker BThe man is incredibly dangerous.
Speaker BLike he's.
Speaker BHe's a snake.
Speaker BHe's so happy to play both sides.
Speaker AFormer master of Whisperers.
Speaker BHe's probably.
Speaker BHe might be the only person in Westeros who could get away with talking to the king like that.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker BI would say especially because I think they've done a good job of.
Speaker BLarys either knows what you want to hear or what you need to hear throughout the.
Speaker BAnd he.
Speaker BThroughout the course of the series and he will.
Speaker BHe will play things accordingly.
Speaker AWhile we're on these scenes with Larys and King Aegon.
Speaker AFormer King Aegon.
Speaker AWere you as surprised as Larys to see the Lannisters appearance?
Speaker AI could have sworn he died at sea in the battle in the first episode.
Speaker AOf course we know his brother's a wee bit dead.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWell, we just never saw anything happen to him.
Speaker AI suppose that was it.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BYeah, that's.
Speaker AThat's much more.
Speaker AIt's one of those.
Speaker AIf you don't see the body in this type of show.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI want to talk about another scene specifically and how good it was.
Speaker AI think the scene between Rhaenyra and Damon in the sept was another shine sign that this show's doing really well.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AIt's well written.
Speaker AI thought that it was smart to set it in the sept in order to accomplish two things.
Speaker AOne, you can see how well written it is by having them speak Valerian or having to speak that and you read it.
Speaker AAnd two, it reminds us Rainier is still pretty stung by their refusal to anoint her as queen or recognize her as queen.
Speaker AAnd she has that great line that's she's just kind of scared.
Speaker AAnd it's something crouched, something formless.
Speaker AIt feels like it's going to get her.
Speaker AShe can't even put her finger on what it is.
Speaker AEvery.
Speaker AYou know, she is the queen.
Speaker AShe got what she wants.
Speaker ABut something out there that was great.
Speaker CThat was great writing.
Speaker CAnd the Damon saying you hear the wind blow through these high towers but anything.
Speaker CThey're an omen.
Speaker CBut it's just the wind.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ADamn good.
Speaker AWhen I first watched that I thought that is good.
Speaker AAnd I did happen to catch it a second time and that line really stuck out to me as well.
Speaker AIt's kind of a really smart line from Damon.
Speaker CTwo very poetic images there back to back and just pure Acting having.
Speaker CHaving them do this pretty serious conversation in Valerian.
Speaker CYou know, you think about how do you learn those lines?
Speaker CAnd like, what.
Speaker CHow to emphasize.
Speaker CEspecially Matt Smith is like emphasizing very specific things in the Valyrian.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker CWhich, you know, it's not just like, maybe in years past, like, you know, they drop a line here, there.
Speaker CBut this is like a very emotive conversation happening.
Speaker CI can't.
Speaker CCan you guys remember one that was that involved?
Speaker BNo, because usually it's like that.
Speaker BThere's a little bit, but this is a back and forth.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AIt's one of those scenes where it's hard to credit the actor or the director or maybe both.
Speaker ASurely the director, you know, had the real English version in front of her and said, really emphasize the word blah or whatever.
Speaker ABut I'm sure he knew it.
Speaker CBut then he even worked some comedy into some of the ways that he's doing things.
Speaker CAnd I'm always just.
Speaker CActors impress me that they can remember lines in their native language, much less however the hell they learned how to do these.
Speaker CThis dialogue.
Speaker ASince we're in spoilers.
Speaker AThis is a bit of a spoiler for an upcoming episode, though.
Speaker AIt's not huge.
Speaker ADon't.
Speaker AIt could be right or wrong.
Speaker AI've saw at least three different people online, say, about Unbent and Unbroken.
Speaker AWell, that was a nice table setting episode.
Speaker AOr the one that was phrased the most interestingly was said, well, that was the calm before the storm.
Speaker AHuh.
Speaker ASo, all right.
Speaker AI suspect the next episode might have a little bang.
Speaker ADon't know why they didn't say anything.
Speaker ASpoiler.
Speaker AOther than that, it does leave us with a couple of things.
Speaker AWe got Cole's destitution, Damon discovering that the leadership of the City Watcher murdered Allison and Helena trapped in the walls of the Red Keep with a cat and a rat.
Speaker AThose are.
Speaker AThose are some.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker ACliffhangers for.
Speaker BAnd.
Speaker BOh, and.
Speaker BAnd lights out.
Speaker BSo they're in the dark there too.
Speaker CI mean, I loved that scene where they're like, we should try this way.
Speaker COh, it's blocked.
Speaker CWe'll just go back.
Speaker CWe can't.
Speaker CThe door is shut.
Speaker CThis universe obviously has always done the frailty of existence at that point really well.
Speaker CBut then she drops the light and it's like, okay, we're two of the wealthiest, most powerful people in this realm, and nobody knows that we're stuck in the wall.
Speaker CYeah, let's see what happens.
Speaker AI suppose it does make sense to shut the door behind you so it doesn't look like you left or it'd be harder to catch you.
Speaker AYeah, I guess the door would kind of lock or be too heavy to push in that direction.
Speaker AI don't know.
Speaker CThe door opened into the passage.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CSo if they pushed it shut, it'd be hard to pull it.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYou can't pry it open.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AI think it's a good episode for.
Speaker AHighly likely we'll return to it.
Speaker BYou know, I thought this is just a note, but I wonder, you know, we kind of almost.
Speaker BI think it was.
Speaker BAdam said maybe there was some course correction in House of the Dragons.
Speaker BAnd I've been interested to see how many of the past episodes have been.
Speaker BHave been written and directed by women specifically.
Speaker BAnd I, I suspect that there is an attention being paid to aspects that make scenes like Renera in the Sept. That much more impactful.
Speaker BSo kudos to the, the writers too, and, and hopefully for whoever's in charge putting, maybe putting some, some new perspectives in there.
Speaker AAgreed.
Speaker AAnd that may be why it's working so well.
Speaker BYeah, I mean, I like it and I do feel like.
Speaker BI just feel like they're doing some good things with the writing.
Speaker BIt's Game of Thrones.
Speaker BIt's not subtle.
Speaker BNot all subtle at least, but there's no.
Speaker BThere's some good stuff there.
Speaker ABut, you know, I'll praise the production for as long as I. I live.
Speaker ALooks great, for sure.
Speaker AAll right.
Speaker AWith that, we're going to move into the movie Warfare.
Speaker AIt's also streaming on HBO Max.
Speaker ASo this is the movie directed by both Alex Garland and Ray Mendoza.
Speaker AGarland's known for his work in directing Civil War Men, Annihilation and Ex Machina.
Speaker AMendoza is not that well known.
Speaker AHe's had some production credits.
Speaker ABut it's Mendoza who was involved in the conflict.
Speaker AThat's recreated here and it's almost recreated in real time.
Speaker AAnd I alluded to the big part of the story.
Speaker AIt's.
Speaker AIt's not a mystery what this is about.
Speaker AThat's not the spoiler part.
Speaker AIt's a dangerous mission for a platoon of Navy seals in Iraq.
Speaker AGets even more so dangerous because they get pinned in a house that they've taken over in the middle of.
Speaker AI forget the city.
Speaker BYeah, real, real place, real situation.
Speaker BThat's the movie Ramadi.
Speaker BIt was in Ramadi.
Speaker BMovie makes it clear right at the beginning that this, this movie is what the events are based on.
Speaker BThe participants memories.
Speaker BMore than anything, more than anything else, it's based on their memories.
Speaker AAnd in fact, co director Ray Mendoza's character is Reservation Dogs actor Young Pharaoh.
Speaker AHe is on communications during most of this battle.
Speaker AAnd that's who Mendoza was in real life.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThis movie almost works like a report, like a.
Speaker ALike a journal entry.
Speaker BLike straight.
Speaker BYeah, straightforward.
Speaker AI'll probably refer to it a lot as a recreation and not as a movie because it's.
Speaker AThat's its goal.
Speaker BYou know what I thought was interesting?
Speaker BI. I like that idea.
Speaker BI think that.
Speaker BThat this.
Speaker BYou saying that it reads like a report, plays like a report.
Speaker BI think I don't have.
Speaker BI don't have it quite stuck together in my brain yet, but I think that made sense of something I was thinking about.
Speaker BAnd I'm sure some people didn't like this, but that's how.
Speaker BWe don't really know anything about these characters until they're dropped in.
Speaker BAll we see is who they are, and all we really need to know is that they're trying to stay alive.
Speaker BAnd I think that you saying that it's like a report.
Speaker BIt's like, yes, you're brought right in, and it's like all you need to do is that these guys are trying to save alive, stay alive, and keep each other alive.
Speaker BHere's what happened.
Speaker AIt's a document, if you want to call it that, too.
Speaker AI think it does a stellar job.
Speaker AThe first 45 to 60 minutes had me hooked because of palpable tension creating anxiety in me.
Speaker AAnd it's.
Speaker AYou knew something was going to happen in any minute.
Speaker AI know there's a lot of downtime where they're setting up and they're simply establishing where they're going to be in this house.
Speaker AAnd that takes up many minutes of screen time, longer than any movie would probably dedicate to it.
Speaker ABut I like that because it allows you to get settled in.
Speaker AAnd you know that without a conflict in the literary sense, in the movie sense of the word, a conflict has to happen in order for there to be a movie.
Speaker AWell, you know what that's going to be, most likely.
Speaker ASo that helped to develop the tension that I think you.
Speaker AYou want to feel.
Speaker ABecause if this is going to be a almost documentary, well, you have to feel what they were feeling to.
Speaker ATo get the point, the setting up and stuff, too.
Speaker BLike, I'm, you know, I think sometimes, like, processes can be interesting.
Speaker BSo I found that interesting.
Speaker BBut it also reminded me, like, when I talk with my own brother who's in the military.
Speaker BHe's in the National Guard now, but he was active duty.
Speaker BI just get this sense and you kind of see it and like, these are like.
Speaker BLike very Very like professional, capable people who are.
Speaker BThey have a job to do or there to do it, who are being.
Speaker BWho the, who are being given orders by, you know, politicians who are not, you know, that was, that was, that's, that's me bringing something in.
Speaker BBut it reminded me like when I talk with my brother about what he does, as much as he can say about it or about his, his soldiers, you know, like they're, they're really professional, like they're smart.
Speaker BThey're here to do a job.
Speaker BThat process part reinforced it for me that like these guys are.
Speaker BThey're professionals.
Speaker AYeah, I'm with you.
Speaker AThe process is interesting.
Speaker AIt's a process.
Speaker AI bet a certain percentage of us have no idea what it is or how to do it.
Speaker AAnd I thought that.
Speaker AI'm with you.
Speaker AI thought that was interesting.
Speaker AAnd when I queued this up, I was really happy.
Speaker AI started watching it because I remembered pretty quickly, oh yeah, this is the movie that was sort of sold advertised as a pretty realistic account of what happened or as realistic as maybe it could be.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd I thought, okay, that's what I was hoping it was.
Speaker AIn fact, I will say that when it's at its most disturbing is when the movie switches to these 30 seconds of silence where you're looking at things from the drones and all you hear are the communications between those people.
Speaker BAnd it's scary because like you're being given the context of what you're seeing, whether it's like, oh, those little dots down there are soldiers running, or like, oh, those little dots down there are people converging to try and kill you, you know?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd it gives you that quiet, that eerie quiet.
Speaker AThe eye in the sky that's always watching versus the ear splitting noise of, of death and chaos at the.
Speaker AOn the ground.
Speaker BYeah, it's, it's, it's.
Speaker BI mean, I think we've.
Speaker BIt's the same kind of unreal feeling that we see, I think we get with drone footage in real life where it just seems so divorced from the actual carnage unfolding.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThis movie was only 95 minutes, which shocked me.
Speaker ALooking back, I felt like it was longer.
Speaker AAnd I don't mean that in a bad way.
Speaker AI feel like it exhausted me.
Speaker AI felt trapped in the.
Speaker AI was in their shoes of the seals and I was just eager for the other group of seals to come and help them get out.
Speaker AYou knew at least some of them had to get out because of.
Speaker AIt's told from the account.
Speaker AThey say this at the very beginning on a Black screen.
Speaker AThis is told from the account of people who lived it as much as possible.
Speaker BThey definitely do a good job when, when they're trapped basically when they're stuck in that house and they do a great job.
Speaker BLike there's a book, Parade's End by Ford Maddox Ford, and he was a officer in the First World War.
Speaker BAnd the last book in the parades or the third book in Parade's End is entitled A Man Could Stand Up.
Speaker BAnd what it's referring to is the main character, Captain Tchen said, thinking like in a normal time, like a man can stand up on a hill.
Speaker BBut now if you stand up, you're going to get shot in the head and killed.
Speaker BAnd I think that this movie did a good job of that kind of transformation where it's like you can't even go up the stairs, you can't even go into that room, you can't even do whatever because like war has utterly transformed the geography that you're, that you're in, you know, and, and, and we're, and I think for, for me, they did a very good job of kind of making me feel that transformation.
Speaker BLike you can't, you can't look through the window.
Speaker BSomeone could shoot you in the head.
Speaker BYou know, a man could stand up.
Speaker BBut not today.
Speaker AIt's very good.
Speaker AI didn't press you when you told me that this movie wasn't what I thought it was.
Speaker AI thought I'd save it for here.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd I'm betting that you and I both liked it a lot because there's no jingoism at play here.
Speaker BThat was kind of exactly it.
Speaker BAnd it doesn't turn into, at least as I read it, the core tension of the movie, besides just surviving is they're trying to get two of their badly injured comrades out of there.
Speaker BIt's not really a movie about killing people, about killing the enemy.
Speaker BPresumably some other guys die, but it's not which.
Speaker BWhich you know, but it's not really about them like American soldiers killing.
Speaker BIt's about American soldiers trying to save their friends and, and survive themselves in a very tense and scary situation.
Speaker BAnd that's.
Speaker BThat surprised me.
Speaker BI thought there was going to be more of a battle as opposed to what we were given.
Speaker AYeah, you're exactly right.
Speaker AMendoza and Garland choose not to even.
Speaker AFocus isn't the right word.
Speaker ABut look upon any of the Iraqis deaths.
Speaker AI'm guessing that they, you know, had to kill some of them.
Speaker AI don't even know that the camera really showed it much.
Speaker AYou just assume I think that worked.
Speaker BFor me because it felt too, from the perspective of the soldiers, like, we don't know who these people are.
Speaker BWe don't know where they are.
Speaker BYou know, there's a couple times where they're shooting out the window.
Speaker BThey're not really shooting at anybody.
Speaker BThey're just trying to keep.
Speaker BIf anyone's out there, keep their head down.
Speaker BThat worked for me.
Speaker BI do.
Speaker BObviously, you know, anything portraying war is complex.
Speaker BAnd the people on the other side, of course, are as human as the American soldiers.
Speaker BBut I don't think that that was a choice that was made to dehumanize.
Speaker BI think that was a choice made because we are so, like it said at the beginning, this is from the memory of the soldiers.
Speaker BAnd so we are in the point of view of the American soldiers.
Speaker BThere's another story to be told here from the men who fought the American stories, but that's not the story we're telling today.
Speaker AYeah, and you mentioned early on, we don't get the background of these men.
Speaker AThat's for movies like American Sniper.
Speaker AThat's for those kinds of movies.
Speaker AIt's not a hero movie.
Speaker AIt's not a high five movie.
Speaker AIt's not a we made it out kind of movie.
Speaker AIt's just a documentary documentation.
Speaker AAnd it's one of those movies about war that's actually presented almost without comment.
Speaker AAnd by presenting it without comment, it does make, I think, an argument I'll always remember to.
Speaker BNot always remember.
Speaker BSorry.
Speaker BI always remember.
Speaker BAnd this is.
Speaker BThis is a quote of a quote, so I can't remember it.
Speaker BBut in Roger Ebert's review of the movie Platoon, he quotes someone else who talks about, like.
Speaker BLike, basically, war movies kind of always break down because at a certain point, it all seems kind of fun and exciting.
Speaker BAnd Roger Ebert was citing Platoon is like, a movie that didn't do that.
Speaker BAnd I think that this movie accomplished that too, where, like, it just.
Speaker BJust from putting yourself in the shoot without, like, by refusing to give us, like, a coherent narrative of, like, what.
Speaker BWhat is quote unquote, like, going on in the overall battle.
Speaker BI think it managed that trick where we're just with these guys who don't really have a good idea what's going on.
Speaker BThey're doing their best, and some of them will go on to star in Beef.
Speaker AOh, Charles Melton, you know, he's good.
Speaker ABut.
Speaker BBut I think they made.
Speaker BIt was just side note, I get such face blindness with everyone in uniforms.
Speaker BBut it was fun to see.
Speaker BLike, okay, there's Cosmo Jarvis, there's.
Speaker BThe cast was good, but, yeah, I really.
Speaker BI really think that this.
Speaker BThat was kind of what I was.
Speaker BI think one of the ways it surprised me too.
Speaker BAnd that's kind of what I was thinking of when I said that is, you know, sometimes war movies seem like a.
Speaker BLike, violent laser tag, you know, just a sport, whereas this did not have that feel at all.
Speaker AYeah, that was.
Speaker AHis goal is.
Speaker AHere's what it's like.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BWhich Thumbs up.
Speaker BYou know, that's.
Speaker BThat's a compliment.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AYou know, how fascinating was it, though?
Speaker AI don't even know what the mission was like.
Speaker AI know we know the town.
Speaker BThe barest bones is that they were supporting another unit, and we don't really.
Speaker AKnow more than that, and that's fine because it.
Speaker AThat helps in seeing its goal.
Speaker AI thought the performances were good.
Speaker AYou mentioned Charles Melton there top to bottom.
Speaker AJoseph Quinn in agony.
Speaker AWill Poulter actively trying to fight.
Speaker AThe onset of PTSD was pretty harrowing.
Speaker BAnother choice that the movie made that I think was good.
Speaker BI think this is very sensitive was the continual reminder that there's a family trapped in here with them, you know, and there's not.
Speaker AIgnore that.
Speaker BThat.
Speaker BThat was an additional, like, reminder, you know, like, as the house is being destroyed by the combat, like, the.
Speaker BThe pain of the people who live there.
Speaker BI really thought they did a good.
Speaker BYou know, and it was almost.
Speaker BIt was a scary situation, too, because you could see how, you know, you've got soldiers trying to keep an eye on these families who don't speak each other's language.
Speaker BThe soldiers don't want to hurt anyone, but it's getting increasingly desperate and.
Speaker BAnd, you know, people have been.
Speaker BThe battle's been going on their head.
Speaker BHeads.
Speaker BHeads have.
Speaker BHeads have had concussions happen.
Speaker BYou can see how something could have.
Speaker BCould have really broken away.
Speaker BBut I loved.
Speaker BI thought they did that really well.
Speaker BAnd I thought to.
Speaker BTo almost end on a picture that we're supposed to understand is those families helps to remind us that, like, there was more happening there than just those soldiers trying to survive.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BLike, it's.
Speaker BIt's like this geopolitical tragedy just exploded on everyone's head there.
Speaker AMm.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AIt's powerful.
Speaker AIt's a pretty good movie.
Speaker BI was.
Speaker BI was surprised.
Speaker BNot Rah Rah, which I.
Speaker BNot jingoistic, intense, respectful of the.
Speaker BOf the.
Speaker AThe.
Speaker BThe men without.
Speaker BI don't feel like anyone here is.
Speaker BIs made to be a superman.
Speaker BYou know, just kind of normal guys who've trained a lot and are Trying to do the best they can.
Speaker BAnd there's some real.
Speaker BI. I remember something Phil Clay once said about, like, he real.
Speaker BLike, he.
Speaker BHe the writer of Redeployment, who's an Iraq War veteran.
Speaker BJust talking about how he.
Speaker BHow he realized once when he was out and about, he's like, I couldn't walk down that.
Speaker BLike, he can see a street.
Speaker BHe's like, I couldn't go and walk down that street because, you know, if he was away from the other soldiers and everything.
Speaker BAnd I think that is part of what this movie does, that transformation of, like, I couldn't walk down that street.
Speaker BI couldn't go there every.
Speaker BYou know, like, if I go outside, I could be destroyed.
Speaker BLike, the.
Speaker BThe transformation of the world that we live in through combat.
Speaker BVery, very harrowing, for sure.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd I think we need these movies, books, documentations of what that's like.
Speaker AIf there's been a recent war.
Speaker BYeah, I agree.
Speaker BI think that it is an important.
Speaker BLike, obviously there are politicians who make these decisions, but at least in theory.
Speaker BAt least in theory, you know, this is reflecting the will of the electorate, the will of the governed.
Speaker BAnd I think, you know, it's a serious and sobering thing to ask somebody to risk themselves mentally, morally, spiritually and physically in a way that.
Speaker BThat we ask our soldiers or we ask of our soldiers.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AEven if you're callous enough to think it's just money.
Speaker AWell, here's where.
Speaker AHow's your money?
Speaker AThis is your money being.
Speaker BHow's your money being spent?
Speaker BYep.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ABut it's a lot more than that.
Speaker ASo if you make that decision, that heavy, crucial decision to put people on the ground in war or otherwise, then this, you know, you probably need to see what that's like as much as you can.
Speaker AI think.
Speaker AYeah, the movie does a good job of that.
Speaker AWell, I think that's it for us.
Speaker AAnd we'll remind you, if your traveling companion says, you're a horrible person, it doesn't mean you can't stab your bully.
Speaker AHave a good week, everyone.






