Taking It Down comes out this week with two episodes, and this, the first, offers thoughts that are all without spoilers.
Blaine begins with a welcome and overview of the first non-spoiler show (0:03), but when Donovan joins, he questions the existence of UMass (2:13).
The hosts get into television with Ken Burns, controversy, and his new documentary 'The American Revolution' on PBS (3:56). Has he lost his touch? From there, it's short thoughts on 'The Beast in Me' from Netflix and how Matthew Rhys and Claire Danes can do no wrong (14:01). They continue a few ideas on 'IT: Welcome to Derry' (17:09) and praise the energy of 'Death by Lightning' on Netflix (25:15). They can't say much about 'Plur1bus' on Apple TV, but they try, especially about the creators (32:26) before moving into the Netflix film 'Frankenstein' and how it differs from other famous adaptations (34:53).
For more, visit The Alabama Take website with this link.
To sign up for the site's newsletter, visit the link here.
To help both the podcast and The Alabama Take site itself, consider making a donation of any size with the link here.
Hello, Happy Thanksgiving Week.
Speaker AIf you're listening as we release.
Speaker AI hope you are.
Speaker AThat's the way you should do it today.
Speaker AYou should for.
Speaker AFor sure.
Speaker AIt's a full episode of Non Spoiler talk on TV and streaming.
Speaker AIt's what we do.
Speaker AWe break down streaming and TV in ways that won't ruin it.
Speaker AIf you haven't watched anything, we do that in the first half and then usually we'll take a short break in the episode and return to you to specific, singular examples if you have seen the episode or episodes or movie or whatever it is.
Speaker AIt's a special week, though.
Speaker AHopefully it's special because you've got more time on your hands, you got more things to do with family and they help you enjoy life even more.
Speaker ABut also it's special because we have two episodes this week.
Speaker AThis is one of two.
Speaker AToday's episode.
Speaker AWe do not get into examples or specifics.
Speaker ASo you can use it to figure out if you will like or dislike a series or a movie.
Speaker ALet's run down what we'll talk about.
Speaker AWe'll discuss the American Revolution from PBS and Kim Burns the Beast in Me on Netflix with Claire Danes and Matthew Reese as the stars.
Speaker AThe HBO show Welcome to Derry and how it's different than other HBO shows in more than one way.
Speaker AThe historical thriller on Netflix, Death by Lightning, which covers the assassination of President Garfield, I'm sure you all remember.
Speaker AAnd then we'll get some broad recommendation like thoughts on the Apple TV series Pluribus.
Speaker APretty popular show right now.
Speaker AIt's made by Breaking Bad creator Vince Gilligan.
Speaker AOh, and we'll tack on some brief takes on the recent incarnation of Frankenstein on Netflix from Guillermo del Toro.
Speaker AThings pile up.
Speaker AWe talk about that, too.
Speaker AWell, let's get to it and let Donovan give some input, too.
Speaker BAlabama take projection.
Speaker AAnd here he is.
Speaker AAnd here I am, too.
Speaker ABack with him.
Speaker AIt's Donovan.
Speaker AHe's the man with the most money on any action game in your area.
Speaker BI bet it all on you, Mass.
Speaker BAnd I need a new place to live.
Speaker AListeners.
Speaker ACan you support him with you?
Speaker BMatt?
Speaker BI'm sorry, I just went up, but I'm fascinated with UMass as a concept.
Speaker BLike there are people out there that attend UMass football games and give money to this program.
Speaker AThe thing that kills me is when you, when you sent me a message, it said they have boosters.
Speaker BThey do.
Speaker AThat's an interesting concept.
Speaker BThey do.
Speaker AWho boosts UMass athletics?
Speaker BI could get you a name.
Speaker BThe Athletic wrote an article about it and interviewed one of them.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker ASo this is recently researched.
Speaker BThis is real, terrifyingly sad.
Speaker AWith me, of course, my friend, my intelligent CO host, it's Mr. Donovan Reinwald.
Speaker AWe're expecting Adam back soon, but we'll see.
Speaker AIt's usually.
Speaker ASometimes it's three of us, sometimes it's two of us.
Speaker AAnd if I sound stuffy, I sound stuffy to myself, but Donovan says I don't sound.
Speaker BYeah, you don't sound congested.
Speaker AOkay, well, I.
Speaker AThis was why we were off last week, is.
Speaker ADeath came knocking and.
Speaker ANo, it wasn't that bad.
Speaker BAnswered.
Speaker AYeah, it was just prolonged.
Speaker AYeah, it wasn't bad.
Speaker AIt was just prolonged and.
Speaker AAnd tiresome pretty much.
Speaker BWhen I get a cold, that's the kind that I get where it's like, you're not really sick enough that you can't go to work, but you just can't do anything and you can't think.
Speaker AOh, I was at.
Speaker AWell, I was one tier above that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker AI couldn't work.
Speaker BYou were at the straight up.
Speaker BI can't think.
Speaker BI'm just miserable.
Speaker AYeah, no fever, but I definitely can't work.
Speaker BYeah, I get you.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AI hate that it's Thanksgiving week.
Speaker BIt is Thanksgiving week.
Speaker BWhat are you thankful for, Blaine?
Speaker AYeah, thankful for all this great television we got this week.
Speaker BAh, that's nice.
Speaker BI was.
Speaker BI was.
Speaker AYou were thinking more spiritual.
Speaker BI was thinking spiritual things.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker AExcuse me.
Speaker AWe have a.
Speaker AThere's nothing says Thanksgiving like another entry in Ken Burns Au vieux or canon, whatever.
Speaker AAnd this time he's tackling, if I'm getting this right, the American Revolution.
Speaker BThat is correct.
Speaker AYou and I have both watched.
Speaker AWell, you've watched some of it and I've watched a little of it.
Speaker BBlaine, let me get the New England take.
Speaker BLet me give you the New England take on this series.
Speaker BI'm gonna tell you right now.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker BI was after church.
Speaker AAre they hot under the collar?
Speaker BWe were at church talking about this.
Speaker BWe already talked out about how they missed something about Connecticut.
Speaker BSo the people are informed.
Speaker AWell, don't spoil it here.
Speaker BWell, okay.
Speaker BI'm not going to tell you about the French.
Speaker BCan you spoil the American Revolution?
Speaker BI mean, we have the fourth of July every year.
Speaker AOh, that's what that's for.
Speaker AI thought that was just to ensure that dogs and cats don't come near your house for a year.
Speaker BWould you like to give your animal a nervous disorder?
Speaker AYou've watched both episodes.
Speaker AI think there are two out.
Speaker BThere's two or three.
Speaker BDarn you.
Speaker BI think darn near the whole thing's out.
Speaker AOh, I thought he was doling about.
Speaker AI don't think two or three a week.
Speaker BMaybe I'm wrong, but.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker BI think.
Speaker BI think a bunch of it's out.
Speaker AI've watched a lot of that first episode.
Speaker ABut what did you think of it so far?
Speaker BMy review.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BFor lots of things lately it feels like has been if you didn't like it before, you're not gonna like it now, but if you do like it, you will like it.
Speaker BSo I see.
Speaker AThat's my.
Speaker AThat's my question mark right there.
Speaker AIs because his style is entrenched in American television and filmmaking.
Speaker ABut I do.
Speaker AI don't know why he's not tinkering with it more now that filmmaking can do the miraculous Ken Burns productions feel especially antiquated.
Speaker BI don't know.
Speaker BIt's a throwback style.
Speaker BIt's a very almost classic documentarian style.
Speaker BI suspect that the reasons behind this have things to do with.
Speaker BWith authority and.
Speaker BAnd sort of the like.
Speaker BAnd I mean that with, like, lower a authority.
Speaker BLike, this feels authoritative, you know, like this feels like, you know, for better or for worse, it feels like a school project.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BIt feels like instead of something that's like flashy, flashy, flashy, flashy.
Speaker BBut maybe you're not getting all the content across.
Speaker BLook, I like it.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThe last Ken Burns piece I watched in full was his meditation on Vietnam.
Speaker BDid you watch all of that?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BThat was very good, very sad.
Speaker AAnd I found it both overwhelming and insightful at the same time.
Speaker AI liked it a lot, but I think it was boosted by Burns having footage to use.
Speaker BSo that has been.
Speaker BI actually am not super duper annoyed with.
Speaker BWith that.
Speaker BBut this is really the first time he's had.
Speaker BHe's never really done anything from before the dawn of photography, you know, for the Civil War.
Speaker BOf course.
Speaker BWe do have some photographs, things like that.
Speaker BYou know, you have portraits, you have illustrations, you have drawings.
Speaker BBut he is filling things in with.
Speaker BWith reenactors, which does have a little bit of like old school history channel about it.
Speaker BI thought it was fine.
Speaker BOr maybe I should say I thought it was fine.
Speaker BAnd I found that the story being told and the people being consulted to tell the story.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BWere very interesting.
Speaker BAnd those.
Speaker BThose were really just moving me along.
Speaker BIn my opinion.
Speaker AI. I just oscillated from.
Speaker AThis is horrible to say.
Speaker AIt's a.
Speaker AIt's a tv.
Speaker AWhat.
Speaker AWhat am I?
Speaker APerson?
Speaker ATV reviewer.
Speaker AI found myself oscillating between very engaged and very bored.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BI think that is fair.
Speaker BI'm already kind of like.
Speaker BI'm already intrigued by the subject matter.
Speaker BI already know some of it about some of it, the background.
Speaker BSo I feel like I had a little.
Speaker BNot that I'm like, know everything about this.
Speaker BI was finding tons of stuff that I didn't know anything about.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BBut I felt like I had a little bit of a leap in where it's like, oh, okay, I didn't know about that part of, you know, whatever.
Speaker BOh, okay.
Speaker BYeah, that's interesting.
Speaker AI think Burns is better when he has moving images to use contemporary images.
Speaker AWhen he's got that one extra arrow in his quiver, I think he's complete and it makes it more fascinating to me.
Speaker BWell, maybe that's part of the work on basically anything of a documentary nature from before the advent of photography and film, you know, I don't know.
Speaker BI really don't know how you get around.
Speaker BGet around it.
Speaker AHe's done baseball and jazz.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BBut there, you know, that's in the era of photography and film.
Speaker ANo, I just thought earlier you had said he hasn't had much with that had film.
Speaker BNo, no, I'm sorry.
Speaker BI said he hasn't had much that has not had film.
Speaker BAs far as I understand the.
Speaker BThis is the first one.
Speaker BLet me restate it.
Speaker BIf I wasn't, I might not have said it clearly.
Speaker BYou know, this is the first documentary he's done where there's no film and then in the case of the Civil War, no photographs.
Speaker BBecause obviously for the Civil War documentary, we do have photographs.
Speaker BSo I think this is the first that he's done that doesn't have that kind of.
Speaker BYou know, it has pictures, it has illustrations.
Speaker BBut it does.
Speaker BBecause there was no means of capturing the human likeness other than, like sitting down and drawing.
Speaker AYou know, it is thoroughly mind blowing that he lived through the American Revolution.
Speaker BAnd Civil War, and we still have him with us here today.
Speaker AHe was kind of getting a little dipping his toe in the controversy areas of America, which is not Ken Burns.
Speaker ADid you see this?
Speaker AUh, yeah.
Speaker AHe was getting some pushback on.
Speaker BI don't think so.
Speaker AWell, as much as you possibly can.
Speaker BNo, I mean, I'm sorry, I didn't.
Speaker BI didn't see it is what I meant was what I meant by that.
Speaker ASome people were doing a little finger wagging that the founders should not ever be shown in a harsh light.
Speaker BOh, I hate that shit.
Speaker BI'm sorry.
Speaker BStuff.
Speaker BI'm gonna make a plug right here.
Speaker BOne of the historians that is consulted during this documentary is a guy named Rick Atkinson.
Speaker BAnd he, he's a really, really great popular historian.
Speaker BHe wrote a trilogy about the American army in the world for the Second World War.
Speaker BAnd in 2019 he wrote a wonderful book called the British Are Coming.
Speaker BAnd he's writing three books again, just through the whole revolution.
Speaker BIf you like, if you like this.
Speaker BThere was stuff about the reaction of the, the colonial governors in the south, the panic and the way that they said, then said some of them were like, okay, well to enslave people, like if you join up with the British and help protect us, you'll get your freedom.
Speaker BAnd the way that our founding fathers, George Washington especially reacted with stuff I had never heard of before.
Speaker BI mean they were, they couldn't believe it.
Speaker BThey thought this was just like the worst thing.
Speaker BPeople.
Speaker BIt's very interesting.
Speaker BIt's all part of the portrait.
Speaker BYou know, it's this and that.
Speaker BThat's part of the fascinating thing.
Speaker BYou know, you've got someone like George Washington who exemplifies leadership, you know, even when he's not the best battlefield commander, who at the same time owns people and is an aristocrat from Virginia, but is able, you know, it's fascinating.
Speaker ADid Ken Burns the American Revolution, what did it show you you hadn't already known or thought about?
Speaker BThe American Revolution is just such a broad tapestry.
Speaker BYeah, that there's.
Speaker BFor me it's not just stuff I didn't know about, but it's almost connecting event.
Speaker BLike there's things that I'm like, well, I know about that, but I know about it in isolation and so like kind of connecting it together.
Speaker BIt's like, oh, okay.
Speaker AThat was exactly what I.
Speaker AEven the hour and a half I watched of episode one, I was thinking, oh shit, yeah, that was happening at the same time.
Speaker BSome of the really, I thought some of the really interesting stuff is looking at our ill fated Canadian adventure during the revolution, you know, we attacked, we, I think captured Montreal and attacked Quebec.
Speaker BWe were repulsed.
Speaker BBenedict Arnold was there and some of the western fighting and then the relationship of the Native Americans to the British and the Americans, the different Native American states, which were not a monolith by any means in there.
Speaker AIt's hard to keep all in your head.
Speaker BIt is really.
Speaker BI have been enjoying it too because years ago during the first Trump presidency, this must have been 2019, I went to the Smithsonian and they had an exhibit looking at the American Revolution as a global war, so featuring stuff from the French and Spanish perspectives, you know, because the French and The Spanish, both, they were fighting a war that our war was a small, was a, was a theater of.
Speaker BReally fascinating.
Speaker BJust making the picture bigger is really, really interesting.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BIf you don't like it, you're probably not going to like it.
Speaker BIf you do, you might stay up too late.
Speaker AIt's almost like you've zoomed in on one part of the painting and you forget to take away the microscope and just look at it as a whole.
Speaker AThat's what I do.
Speaker AAll right.
Speaker AAlso, something I want to talk about.
Speaker ACompletely different, but its own little American Revolution on its own is actually.
Speaker AWell, it takes place in the same area.
Speaker ANext, the Netflix thriller the Beast in Me.
Speaker BI love those sad eyes.
Speaker AYeah, I know.
Speaker AIt's got a lot of high profile names both as stars and behind the camera.
Speaker AClaire Danes and Matthew Rees.
Speaker AMan, they act their asses off.
Speaker AShe's an author whose new next door neighbor is definitely a real estate tycoon and maybe a wife murderer.
Speaker BI didn't even know the.
Speaker BI mean, I know the premise now because I looked up reviews, but when I was learning about this, I didn't know anything about the premise, but I just saw Matthew Reese and Claire Danes.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd I'm like, that's got an 80% chance not to be a waste of my time.
Speaker BLike at least 80% because they're so good.
Speaker AJust on an entertainment level.
Speaker BYeah, exactly.
Speaker AI give a lot of credit to Rhys and Danes because they, during the first, second and third episodes, all of which I've watched, they take my head out of.
Speaker ADid Matthew Reese's character murder his wife?
Speaker AYou kind of forget about that.
Speaker AWell, not completely, but like you focus on so much, so many other things.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThe creator and handwriter is Gabe Rotter and he's.
Speaker AI guess he's only known for working on the X Files.
Speaker BYeah, I'd never really heard of him.
Speaker AI don't know if that bit of information tips it's had toward how to think about the series or how it might be a little different.
Speaker BSo like the aliens to tell you.
Speaker ANoted that Conan o' Brien's an executive producer too.
Speaker BOh, interesting.
Speaker BWhat is this?
Speaker BThe Simpsons?
Speaker BI know that's very interesting, but.
Speaker ABut Matthew Reese can play gentle and menacing and grief stricken in the same scene.
Speaker BYeah, he's got.
Speaker BIt's incredible range.
Speaker AIt's innate, I think because he just has that look.
Speaker ABut.
Speaker AAnd then you have Claire Danes on the other side who's made a living off of extreme emotions.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd she's doing the same here.
Speaker AAnd also in this show is Jonathan Banks from Breaking Bad.
Speaker ABetter Call Saul.
Speaker BOh, I like him.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BNo, he was in this show.
Speaker BIt's nice to see him.
Speaker AYep.
Speaker ASo you'll be entertained at worst.
Speaker AThat's kind of where I am with it.
Speaker BAnd you were talking about Matthew Reese's ability to do things in one scene.
Speaker BI just remember scenes in the Americans, especially towards the end, where he had this sadness in him and then there would.
Speaker BThere would be rage and anger, but it was so clearly coming out of this sadness and you just.
Speaker BOh, man.
Speaker BLike you wanted to cry watching it.
Speaker BHe's so good.
Speaker BClaire Dean is good too.
Speaker BI'm not.
Speaker BNot casting any aspersions on her, but I'm just really a big Matthew Reese fan.
Speaker AWell, this one is a.
Speaker AIt's good performance by him.
Speaker AI'm interested to see what they end up doing with his character and you know, how.
Speaker AHow interested are they in.
Speaker AIs he a wife killer or not?
Speaker AI don't, you know, I don't know.
Speaker AYeah, you and I both continued watching it.
Speaker AWelcome to Dairy on hbo.
Speaker AI've.
Speaker AI've really no intention of stopping same.
Speaker AIt's.
Speaker BI have no intention of stopping which.
Speaker AIn the Lee in the least.
Speaker ABut here's the thing.
Speaker AWe'll be a couple episodes behind.
Speaker BYeah, I got.
Speaker BI got messed up by one of the episodes releasing.
Speaker BIt's a Sunday show, but one released on Halloween.
Speaker BSo I got mixed up.
Speaker BSo I'm an episode behind.
Speaker BAnd then of course, when you're hearing this, I will be two episodes behind.
Speaker AYeah, that's the thing.
Speaker AHere's my quip.
Speaker AI've got a few quips with welcome to Dairy.
Speaker AI do think it's adhering heavily to the lore of Stephen King rather than trying to tell its own story.
Speaker ASometimes I would.
Speaker AIt's like, which route?
Speaker AWhich road are you want to travel?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ADo you want to travel building lore or do you want to tell me a brand new thing?
Speaker AIt feels a little too chained to check me some boxes for a King universe for.
Speaker ATo plant Easter eggs for fans.
Speaker AI don't know how much involvement King has with this.
Speaker BI don't either.
Speaker BSo you're feeling that it kind of is maybe falling into the same trap that some of those Disney Star wars shows have fallen into, where it's like, tell me a story that I can enjoy without having seen seven seasons of a cartoon and I don't care about all this.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AWell said.
Speaker ABut much, much less annoying.
Speaker BI mean there's definitely like, okay, yeah, they've.
Speaker BThe people making it.
Speaker BI'm gonna shock everyone.
Speaker BThe people making this have seen the it movie that they themselves made.
Speaker BLike, they got the kid, you know, they got the kids.
Speaker BThey got the.
Speaker BBlaine, I don't disagree.
Speaker BBlaine.
Speaker BI do think there's a lot of.
Speaker BLike, these are elements from his fiction.
Speaker BI don't know this particular story well enough to know if it's like, okay, this is straight up from it, or.
Speaker BBut I've read enough of his short fiction and novels to be like, this is from his.
Speaker BHis brain, you know?
Speaker BYeah, this is where his brain is.
Speaker BI mean, we've all seen Stand By Me, right?
Speaker AYep.
Speaker ABut.
Speaker ABut to praise it, though, the child actors they've chosen to play the primary cast are pretty top level.
Speaker AI think that Chris Chalk is incredible.
Speaker AI love a very good actor.
Speaker BI love Chris Chalk.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BHe's very good.
Speaker AYeah, he can do work.
Speaker AHis, dare I say sidekick is Jovan Adepo.
Speaker AI think I pronounced his name right.
Speaker AHe was in the recent Netflix series for Three Body Problem.
Speaker AYeah, he was okay there.
Speaker BBut did you like.
Speaker BYou watch that?
Speaker BDid you like it?
Speaker AIt was okay.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker AIt was interesting concept.
Speaker ASometimes poorly executed.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ABut Chris Chalk plays Dick Calloran and Joven Adepa plays Major Leroy Hanlon, which can get a little confusing for me because they both have these h. Last names with multiple syllables.
Speaker AAnd I'm like, wait, which one did he just say?
Speaker ASo I will call them.
Speaker AI'll call them, respectively, Dick and Leroy.
Speaker AAll right, Just.
Speaker BThat's same for listeners.
Speaker AThat'll help you.
Speaker BThat seems fair.
Speaker ABut I think that they are doing pretty good work.
Speaker AThe lady playing Major Leroy's wife is also doing quite well.
Speaker AAnd one thing that it gets right and makes me wince at sometimes is, is how perfect the credit sequence is for this show.
Speaker AIt is just the balance of nostalgia and fear that welcome to Derry wants to have, I think.
Speaker BYeah, there is an almost.
Speaker BThis is gonna sound weird for a show that's a horror thing about something that scares you to death.
Speaker BIt's almost like maybe they'll really skew this.
Speaker BBut there's almost like a comfort to it.
Speaker BLike, in the same way that, like, at least in these early ones that, like early seasons of Stranger Things, like, oh, kids get in adventures.
Speaker BCool.
Speaker BYou know, you're kind of along for the ride.
Speaker BDoes that make sense?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AKind of like the Stand By Me you mentioned.
Speaker BYeah, exactly.
Speaker BSomething that I didn't know, and I just stumbled across an article for it.
Speaker BApparently the creators for this worked.
Speaker BI thought this was kind of cool.
Speaker BSomething behind the camera worked with one of the main.
Speaker BThere's indigenous characters in this show.
Speaker BWorked with one of the main tribes, including folks who are faculty members at the University of Maine, to try and get their.
Speaker BThere to be, you know, honest.
Speaker BAnd of their depiction of the fictional tribes, I'm like, that's actually.
Speaker BThey probably didn't have to do that.
Speaker BSo I think that's really.
Speaker BI think like it would have.
Speaker BI think it's good they're doing it, but I think it's cool that they like did it because I bet they could have gotten away with not doing it.
Speaker BSo I was.
Speaker BSo I'll just.
Speaker BThey get the.
Speaker BThey get the.
Speaker BThey get the good effort.
Speaker BThe kudos of the week award from.
Speaker AMe now I've seen the most recent one for us being recorded on Sunday.
Speaker AIt was called the Great Swirling Apparatus of Our Planet's Function.
Speaker AI did think it was one of the better episodes because it really helped paint the image of it as an entity rather than a clown.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BBecause it's not.
Speaker BI mean, I think that's the thing that makes it the most scary is it's like it's not.
Speaker BIt's not a personality, you know, like it's in kind of in the same way that, I mean, I think King read his Lovecraft, but some kind of.
Speaker BIn the way that some of like, you know, Lovecraft's things are from.
Speaker BThey're from outside of your reality.
Speaker BThey just don't care about you.
Speaker BYou're nothing to them.
Speaker BYour food, if that.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd it's funny that that for you works, but for me, you have to get me there.
Speaker AYeah, that doesn't scare me too much.
Speaker BInteresting.
Speaker AIf you have something that does not have intent and probably shouldn't have intent, whereas you give me something that does not have intent but should.
Speaker AThat's scary.
Speaker BOkay, interesting.
Speaker ALike the.
Speaker ALike the.
Speaker AThe movie.
Speaker AThe Strangers.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker ALike, what are they doing?
Speaker AAnd then.
Speaker BYeah, there.
Speaker AIt's just.
Speaker AThere's no reason.
Speaker AThey're just doing it.
Speaker BThat.
Speaker BThere.
Speaker BThat's.
Speaker BThat's interesting because.
Speaker BYeah, that.
Speaker BThat concept, like, it works in Lovecraft, it works here for me.
Speaker BOne of my favorite books that I've read recently is a Russian science fiction novel called Roadside Picnic.
Speaker BThe movie Stalker is based on it.
Speaker BAnd the reason it' called Roadside Picnic is because there's an.
Speaker BThere's parts of Earth that have been affected in some way by.
Speaker BBy aliens.
Speaker BThey don't really know what or how.
Speaker BAnd the analogy that's made is it's like just if we.
Speaker BIf we had a roadside picnic and left our trash on the ground.
Speaker BWhat would the ants think about it?
Speaker BAnd we're the ants, obviously, for the aliens.
Speaker BSo it's kind, it's kind of scary.
Speaker BLike we'll just never.
Speaker BWe can't.
Speaker BIt's.
Speaker BWe will never understand because we can't understand.
Speaker BYeah, we're locked out from understanding.
Speaker ADoes it ever startle you that welcome to Derry isn't.
Speaker AIs on HBO front and center, like it's one of their Sunday night primetime HBO shows?
Speaker BI was a little surprised, honestly.
Speaker BI was a little surprised that it's Sunday night.
Speaker BI was a little surprised that they didn't have it running a little bit more before Halloween.
Speaker BI don't know.
Speaker BI'm not in the.
Speaker BI'm not privy to the details of HBO scheduling.
Speaker AI think the task probably took up that time.
Speaker BI mean, I think it is fairly.
Speaker BIt's obviously a fairly popular franchise.
Speaker BSo I assume this is motivated by, you know, one of the breweries in my area did like, they brewed two special IT theme beers for Halloween.
Speaker BYou know, so obviously people.
Speaker BObviously it's recognizable and there's cultural cachet.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BSo possibly that's it.
Speaker BWell, it's a big, It's a big jump from task to welcome to Derry though, for your Sunday night show.
Speaker BIt's a big jump.
Speaker AIt's.
Speaker AIt's jarring.
Speaker AAnd, and we're.
Speaker AWe have no segues here today either.
Speaker AAnd we're going to be jarring some folks for some Thanksgiving dads out there.
Speaker AA little bit more history.
Speaker AHow About Benioff and D.B.
Speaker Aweiss produced historical drama Death by Lightning on Netflix about the oft forgotten president James Caulfield, who just so happened to be assassinated not too many years after Honest abe.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAbout 15.
Speaker AOh, it was.
Speaker BOr 16.
Speaker BMaybe it's 16 years.
Speaker AI was thinking it might be 20, but wow, it's shorter than that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAbraham Lincoln was assassinated in 1865.
Speaker BGarfield ran for president in 1880, I believe was shot in 1881.
Speaker ALike March, something like that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThe show's got a plethora of stars.
Speaker AMichael Shannon is Garfield.
Speaker AMatthew McFadden doing just killer work here.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BOh, man.
Speaker AAs the assassin to be Charles Couteau.
Speaker ABetty Gilpin is Garfield's wife.
Speaker ABradley Whitford is Senator Blaine from Maine.
Speaker AThat's.
Speaker AI didn't make that up.
Speaker AThere's always the welcome Shea Wiggum as a crooked New York senator.
Speaker AAnd they always welcome Nick Offerman as Chester Arthur.
Speaker AAll playing real people, historical figures.
Speaker BI would say that if you like, act.
Speaker BIf you had pitched this to me, I'd be like, who wants to hear about this?
Speaker BBut y'.
Speaker BAll.
Speaker AWait, really?
Speaker BIf you, like, act, you know, it just seems like the kind of thing that, like, it's a historical drama about James Garfield.
Speaker BYou know, you remember him, right?
Speaker BPutting aside everything else, which I also think is good.
Speaker BThat's my spoiler, folks.
Speaker BI enjoyed it.
Speaker BThe acting.
Speaker BWe get everything from folks who are clearly loving chewing the scenery to people who, in their depictions, swing between buffoonery and sensitivity and then some real.
Speaker BI mean, I think the foundation of the show is Matthew McFadden's Guito, and he is.
Speaker BFolks, he is good.
Speaker BThis is the real deal.
Speaker BEverybody's good in it.
Speaker BHe's really good.
Speaker BThis show does not work without him.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AHe somehow manages to be insane enough to where you think, I would never do that.
Speaker ABut also downtrodden enough to think, yeah, I guess I could do that.
Speaker BThere's.
Speaker BThere's a pathos to him, and it swings between, like, there's stuff that's really funny with him, and then there's stuff that'll almost make you.
Speaker BYou cry.
Speaker BLike, you feel so sad for that, that a human being is.
Speaker BHas come to this, or could act like this or could feel like this.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BThere's.
Speaker BThere's some good jokes about how annoying he is.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAll said, it may sound like a dad show.
Speaker AI mean, I guess it is, but.
Speaker BYeah, it doesn't.
Speaker BIt feels like it's.
Speaker BIf it's a dad show, it's not your dad's.
Speaker BJames Garfield, not your parents, not your daddy's.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThere's a wildness to this series where it knows that history is not some thing on a page.
Speaker BBlaine, I think you identified it exactly.
Speaker BWhere it's like, for us, we know this gets swallowed up in the dramas of, you know, World War I and World War II and the.
Speaker BThe 20th century.
Speaker BBut, you know, in this.
Speaker BIn this, like, this stuff mattered, and this was.
Speaker BThis was.
Speaker BIt was a raucous time for everyone, you know, and you've got.
Speaker BYou know, you've got historical figures like Fredley Douglas in the mix.
Speaker BYou've got the Civil War casting its long shadow over everything still.
Speaker BI mean, every single person in America knew someone who had been killed or wounded in the Civil War, and that's still dictating the politics of America.
Speaker BYou've got, I mean, the famously corrupt President Grant, who's a war hero, or he may or may not.
Speaker BYou know, maybe he's just overly swayed by his Friends.
Speaker BBut it is.
Speaker BIt's an America where there's a lot of cynicism about what politics are and can be.
Speaker BAnd into this we world were sort of dropped.
Speaker BAnd unfortunately for us, Guiteau is sort of an idealist as well.
Speaker ASo America really was that cynical at that time.
Speaker BThe Grant administration really was famously corrupt, you know, giving things to friends and things like that.
Speaker BNew York politics were.
Speaker BThere was the machine, like, you know, I don't remember.
Speaker BI'm gonna get mixed up.
Speaker BBut this was the era of, like, Tammany hall politics in New York City.
Speaker BAnd the thing that they're so, you know, they mentioned a couple times, but there was no income tax.
Speaker BSo most.
Speaker BThat's when they're saying 75% of the federal government's revenues comes through New York.
Speaker BThat.
Speaker BBecause that's how the government is getting funded.
Speaker BThey're getting funded with Customs House money.
Speaker BYou know, no income tax yet.
Speaker BNot a lot of these other taxes.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BThat gives New York an outsize pull on the system.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd of course, this is.
Speaker BI'm sorry, Blaine, I didn't mean to.
Speaker BBut this is.
Speaker BThis is an age of deepening wealth inequality.
Speaker BYou know, the rich are getting richer, the poor, who's, you know, who's helping them.
Speaker BWe're going to see the government turn its black.
Speaker BExcuse me.
Speaker BThe.
Speaker BIt's back on the freed black folks of the south, you know, after.
Speaker BAbout which it won't be until the civil rights era that they have that kind of political representation again.
Speaker BOr after the civil rights era, I should say.
Speaker BYou know, it's.
Speaker BIt's.
Speaker BIt's a big old mess.
Speaker AWow.
Speaker AWell, the show itself is fascinating.
Speaker AI think it bears witness.
Speaker AIt's reminiscent of today.
Speaker AThey don't forget to remind you.
Speaker AThis stuff lingers throughout our own history.
Speaker BI feel like they haven't been too cute about it, you know, in the sense of, like, did you get that?
Speaker BIt's about whatever.
Speaker BBut just in the sense that.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BBut the first historian, essentially, Thucydides, who writes his history of the Peloponnesian War, and he says, why am I writing this?
Speaker BAnd he says it's because my opinion is that human nature doesn't change.
Speaker BSo if I write this down and human nature doesn't change, we're always going to be able to learn from my account of the Peloponnese.
Speaker BIt's always going to speak to us.
Speaker BAnd I think history done well, does that.
Speaker AWell, it enlightened me a lot and it entertained me a lot.
Speaker ABut then it slips into.
Speaker AI Think after the four.
Speaker AIt's only four episodes.
Speaker AFourth, fourth and final episode.
Speaker AIt's kind of a powerful series.
Speaker BI, I, I, I'm, I'm three in folks.
Speaker BVery much enjoying it.
Speaker BIt's, it's got incredible energy and it's also, it's also very funny.
Speaker BLike I'm, I'm laughing throughout the show.
Speaker AYeah, it's not dull.
Speaker BIt's not dull.
Speaker AWell, this will be.
Speaker AWe're doing something special this week.
Speaker AWe talked about that at the beginning.
Speaker AWe're splitting our show up into two episodes.
Speaker AThis week.
Speaker AIt's Thanksgiving.
Speaker AYou could probably handle that as why.
Speaker ATwo more things in our non spoiler show today.
Speaker APluribus, Apple tv.
Speaker BHow do I talk about this in non spoiler space?
Speaker AI was so excited to talk about this show with you because I don't know what to say.
Speaker BI assume.
Speaker ALet me get some basics out of the way.
Speaker BYeah, yeah.
Speaker AThere are now four episodes on Apple TV plus or just Apple tv.
Speaker AYou know, I, I really am dying to know what Donovan makes of this.
Speaker AIt's from Vince Gilligan.
Speaker AThat's a brand name these days.
Speaker AIf you even remotely know about Breaking Bad or Better Call Saul, you know him, he's the guy who got those up and running.
Speaker AReally headed those.
Speaker AHe got his start on the X Files though.
Speaker AAgain.
Speaker AAgain we're mentioning it.
Speaker APluribus may have more in common with that than the two AMC dramas.
Speaker AThis series has racy horn a she's a disgruntled fantasy author in the midst of one of the oddest post apocalyptic scenarios I think we've seen in a while.
Speaker AI don't think I'll say more.
Speaker BIt's hard not to say more.
Speaker AWhat did you think about this?
Speaker BI'm intrigued.
Speaker BIs it good?
Speaker BIt's.
Speaker BYeah, I think so.
Speaker BI think it's, I think it's.
Speaker BSometimes that's not right.
Speaker BI think it's pretty well paced.
Speaker BSometimes it goes a little slow.
Speaker BBut I think that's my, I think that's my impatience coming out.
Speaker BAnd I think it's very much high concept.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BLike it's gonna.
Speaker BIt has a pretty intriguing premise and so far, for four episodes, it hasn't been too afraid of following the implications of that premise.
Speaker AI could see so many of the hallmarks of Better Call Saul in the fourth episode.
Speaker AYeah, I could really see that.
Speaker BI see what you mean.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThere's very little I think we could say that wouldn't be spoilers.
Speaker BFolks, at this time, you've probably seen it's been getting great reviews I'd recommend a watch at least.
Speaker AIt was Apple's best debut, I think.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AEven above, like a.
Speaker ALike a severance or something.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BI think it's still hitting number one.
Speaker BI mean, they self report the numbers, so who really knows?
Speaker BBut that's true.
Speaker AWell, last on our list today, before we say goodbye to you, a non spoiler episode, only last on our list is the Netflix.
Speaker AWe're sticking with Netflix again.
Speaker ABouncing back to it, I should say.
Speaker AThe film Frankenstein, made by Guillermo del Toro, putting his own touch on the creation horror piece that it ran in theaters for a couple weeks, and then it landed on Netflix.
Speaker AIt was only in theaters in the major cities, and in this one, I think it's not really a spoiler to say that the monster is not Frankenstein.
Speaker BWell, Frankenstein is the monster, Blaine, in broad terms.
Speaker AWhat'd you think about it?
Speaker BLiked it very much.
Speaker ALike love.
Speaker BI wish I'd seen it in a theater.
Speaker BAlthough I think del Toro usually operates on a pretty high level, I think this is on par with his best.
Speaker BI think it's a great adaptation.
Speaker BHe had this.
Speaker BI'm trying to remember what he said.
Speaker BHe talked about adapting something, and he said, like, adapting is like marrying a widow.
Speaker BHe's like, you've.
Speaker BHe's like, you've got to be respectful, but you also want to dance with her.
Speaker BSo there's a bit of.
Speaker BThere's some really great faithfulness to the source material that he, I think, draws out and makes interesting.
Speaker BThe acting is great.
Speaker BWe've got Oscar Isaac as Victor Frankenstein.
Speaker BWe've got Jacob El Dori as the creature, the hot creature.
Speaker BChristoph Waltz is in it.
Speaker BHe's got Mia Goth playing both Victor Frankenstein's mother and an object of his affections.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BIt's weird.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BAnd it's.
Speaker AYou've read the work by Mary Shelley?
Speaker BI have read Frankenstein, yes.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI have not.
Speaker AI've only read Dracula.
Speaker AOf those sort of classic horrors.
Speaker BI have never.
Speaker BI read the great illustrated version of Dracula, but every time I'm like, I'm gonna read Dracula, I'm like, he's describing the dinner again.
Speaker AYeah, it is a lot like that.
Speaker BIt is.
Speaker AI bet Frankenstein's a better read.
Speaker BIt's very much of its time and what it is.
Speaker BAnd by that, I mean, it's a romantic novel with heightened passions, but Mary Shelley is.
Speaker BI mean, there's a reason it stuck around for so long.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BLike, Mary Shelley tapped in sometimes.
Speaker BThis is not a knock against Mary Shelley.
Speaker BThis is all the novels of this era.
Speaker BEra.
Speaker BSometimes it seems, in my opinion, it's a little florid and overdone, but then when it hits, it hits so good.
Speaker BAnd obviously, she tapped in.
Speaker BShe's a great writer, and she tapped into something primal about us.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ASo is Del Toro doing a adaptation?
Speaker AIs he trying to adhere to the text, or is he trying to do his version of Frankenstein?
Speaker AOr both?
Speaker AI mean, what makes this different?
Speaker BI would say he's doing his version of Frankenstein.
Speaker BHonestly, the things that make it the most different are things I cannot talk about in the non spoiler section.
Speaker BI thought that the ending was really interesting and some of the other things as they go through, honestly.
Speaker BDel Toro is obviously.
Speaker BI mean, this is based on the book, but he is obviously aware of the cinematic history of Frankenstein.
Speaker BOscar Isaac is great as Victor Frankenstein.
Speaker ABut I love him anyway.
Speaker BIt's really.
Speaker BI mean, he's really good in this, but there's really.
Speaker BThere's a.
Speaker BThe focus on the creature is really astounding when we get to his part of it, because it's done, you know, much like.
Speaker BSo the novel Frankenstein.
Speaker AYou keep leaving out the adjective hot.
Speaker AHe's too hot.
Speaker BWell, he's.
Speaker BYou know, he's stitched together.
Speaker BOh, wow.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BHe's made from different pieces.
Speaker BThere's even a great scene.
Speaker BI mean, Oscar Isaac plays it beautifully.
Speaker BThere's this great scene where men are being hanged, you know, criminals are being executed.
Speaker BAnd Isaac goes up and he's feeling around the bodies for body parts.
Speaker BYou know, he's trying to see which one's going to work the best.
Speaker APretty morbid.
Speaker BYeah, very morbid.
Speaker BIt works.
Speaker BOne of the things I did enjoy about it is, you know, the movie of.
Speaker BOr the book.
Speaker BFrankenstein is actually framed, as many novels are, by its.
Speaker BThere's an arctic explorer or a ship in the Arctic, right?
Speaker BAnd there the captain is writing about this man that he's encountered on the ice, Victor Frankenstein.
Speaker BSo Victor is telling his story to the captain, and that's what is happening in this movie.
Speaker BBut at a crucial moment, the monster gets a chance to tell, or the creature gets a chance to tell his story, too, just like Frankenstein does.
Speaker AOkay, I may try to work that one in.
Speaker AI don't know.
Speaker BIt's gothic, it's romantic.
Speaker BSometimes it's over the top, sometimes it's understated.
Speaker BI thought it was very good.
Speaker BIf you don't like Del Toro, you will not like it.
Speaker AWell, I don't know if I do.
Speaker BI think I.
Speaker BHe's.
Speaker BHe's a filmmaker that's just consistently intriguing to me because he'll make something like Pan's Labyrinth, Devil's Backbone, Chronos.
Speaker BHe'll goof around with, like, giant robots in Pacific Rim.
Speaker BHe's interested in adaptation.
Speaker BLots of adaptations.
Speaker BEverything from comic books.
Speaker BYou know, he adapted that.
Speaker BTwo of the.
Speaker BThe Hellboy.
Speaker BWe made two Hellboy movies to Pinocchio.
Speaker AYep.
Speaker AOur friend Raz is a big Del Toro fan.
Speaker BOh, okay.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ARez, I haven't watched my.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWell, there you go.
Speaker AWe're getting close to the end of our episode.
Speaker AI wanted to throw in a couple things, just.
Speaker AI don't know if this will happen.
Speaker ABut now tomorrow's episode will be spoilers of everything we talked about today.
Speaker ASo if you want spoilers, you got a night to catch up on them.
Speaker ABut I will say that next week, when we're not splitting our episodes in two, it could be Train Dreams on Netflix, if you wanted to watch that.
Speaker AAnd we might have some things to say about Stranger Things coming back on the.
Speaker BThat's right, it's coming back.
Speaker AThanksgiving.
Speaker BIt feels like we have to look at it, even though, like, these kids are, you know, they're all 38 now.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThey're rolling around in wheelchairs.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BThey're barely there.
Speaker AWell, for Adam and Donovan, I'm Blaine, and we hope that your Thanksgiving is going well.
Speaker AAnd you know what?
Speaker AWe'll talk.
Speaker AWe'll talk to you tomorrow, too.
Speaker ABye.






