Blaine begins the week with a welcome and quick summary of the episode this week (0:01).
After getting Adam into the co-host's chair, Blaine begins the non-spoiler section and tries to convince him that 'The Pitt' is one of the best and most different medical dramas on TV, but is Adam sold on it (1:44)? The two also talk about the return of 'The White Lotus' on HBO for its third season (13:49).
For the spoiler section, the hosts unpack all the characters of the new third season of 'The White Lotus' from its first episode (23:39).
After 'The White Lotus,' they continue coverage of 'Severance': what do the pairs of the sixth episode have to hint for the back half of the second season (43:41)?
As always, visit The Alabama Take for more podcasts and writings.
Hello, this is taking it down.
Speaker AIf you're new to this podcast, welcome.
Speaker AWe are the working class TV and streaming podcast for the Alabama Take website, which has a whole family of podcasts.
Speaker AIt's been my experience that workers of the world want to know if something's worth watching because they need their time.
Speaker AThat's why we do everything with a non spoiler section to begin and a spoiler section after the break.
Speaker AThis week, regular listeners may note that I'm swapping Donovan with Adam.
Speaker AAll three of us will return as a crew soon, but today Adam and I will begin the no spoiler section with a discussion on the Max medical series the Pit, the return of the HBO series the White Lotus, and we won't say very much about Severance this week in the non spoiler section on the spoiler side, we'll talk about the White Lotus and its first episode back for season three and the sixth episode of Severance.
Speaker AAlabama take projection.
Speaker AOkay, as promised, I'm here with Adam.
Speaker ABut no, Donovan told you that at the top, Donovan is catching the big fish.
Speaker ADonovan's got family, I think affairs happening.
Speaker AThat's fine.
Speaker AAdam was absent last week with musical duties, not Sister Ray Davies, which you should go online and check out because that's going to be a pretty big thing this summer.
Speaker ASister Ray Davies, go check out, especially if you like shoegaze with a few twists involved.
Speaker AYou'll enjoy it.
Speaker AAdam, I did this to Donovan last week and perhaps it's only fair to do it to you as the so called host.
Speaker AI'm gonna give you a show I've been watching and open the floor in this non spoiler section for you to ask questions or talk about it because.
Speaker BYou haven't seen it so far as you know.
Speaker AOh, interesting.
Speaker AThis could be.
Speaker BI have no idea what you're gonna say.
Speaker BI just wanted to throw a wrench in things that would be crazy if.
Speaker AYou had watched it and I didn't.
Speaker BIs it Mad Men?
Speaker ANo, I watched Mad Men.
Speaker AIt's this new show.
Speaker BFor some reason, YouTube TV now has a channel called AMC Stories, which I assumed was going to, you know, greatest hits the first weekend.
Speaker BI believe it started early on a Sunday and I discover it later that day and Natalie says, oh, so you found the Mad Men channel?
Speaker BAs if she'd been like, dreading me finding out that this exists.
Speaker BAnd they've just been playing it on a loop for like three or four weeks now.
Speaker ASo it is a Mad Men channel.
Speaker BIn a way, you know, like what you said.
Speaker BI assumed, like Breaking Bad would come next.
Speaker BThe terror could be on there.
Speaker BThe greatest things they've done.
Speaker BBut no, it's just been so.
Speaker BIf you're ready to talk about Mad Men.
Speaker BI am.
Speaker BI'm there with you.
Speaker BBut tell me about this other program.
Speaker AI'm always ready to talk about Mad Men.
Speaker AI know I started watching the Max medical drama.
Speaker AThe Pit stars Noah Wy and a lot of other great but I suppose kind of unknown actors.
Speaker AIt was created by R.
Speaker AScott Gimmel who worked on ER on NBC quite a lot.
Speaker ASo this is going to make sense.
Speaker AIt's huge difference, huge contrast between the two shows though this one's set in Pittsburgh, it's on Max, which is.
Speaker AAllows for entirely more gruesome scenarios.
Speaker AAnd lastly it covers their emergency department at an hour at a time.
Speaker AI love that the opening episode starts with the primary character, Dr.
Speaker AMichael Robotovich.
Speaker AI think his name is.
Speaker AEverybody calls him Dr.
Speaker ARobbie or just Robbie.
Speaker AStarts with his shift at 7am that's the Noah Wiley character.
Speaker AYou strike me as a guy who does not dig medical shows.
Speaker BWhat.
Speaker BWhat makes you think that?
Speaker AOne thing is when I brought it up in our group text, you didn't really say anything, you didn't reply, you didn't buy.
Speaker BSo you have evidence.
Speaker BI thought you were just inferring based on other personality traits beyond that.
Speaker ASo when I brought it to you and Donovan I assumed that neither of you are big into it.
Speaker AMy.
Speaker AAnd I think it's because the same thing I am never pulled into medical dramas before.
Speaker AIt's because I associate them so heavily with er with Grey's Anatomy which would have been on when we were in college.
Speaker AThose are to me more melodrama than drama.
Speaker AIt in.
Speaker AIn fact I don't know that I've ever watched a medical drama like ever.
Speaker ADonovan in his.
Speaker AIn his reply says that he watched the Nick, which is one I wanted to watch.
Speaker ASo I think I've always associated him with this near soap soap operatic type of writing and acting that's been my.
Speaker BMy read on the medical drama as like a.
Speaker BLike how do you avoid it being a cliche?
Speaker BIt's almost the nicest thing you can say about one is that it's.
Speaker BIt's not like most medical dramas because it seems to be the most closed set genre piece thing that you can do.
Speaker BLike it's almost like oh it's a western.
Speaker BOh, it's a medical drama.
Speaker BOh it's a whatever like going to the doctor.
Speaker BWhy do I want to watch it on tv?
Speaker AI don't that's funny, Adam.
Speaker BI don't.
Speaker BI mean, like the.
Speaker BThe Nick program.
Speaker BI understood it was much buzzed about.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ABut I.
Speaker AIt was also on Cinemax at a time when nobody really had Cinemax.
Speaker BI watched solid amount of the first season.
Speaker AYou did?
Speaker BYeah, I did.
Speaker BJust because I was curious.
Speaker BAnd I like a piece of historical fiction.
Speaker AUhhuh.
Speaker AAnd it also starred one of my favorite actors, Clive Owen.
Speaker BI mean, it was a good show, but one of the things that they're doing is discovering things that we take for granted now.
Speaker BThey're supposed to be these genius doctors who are living in this brutal world.
Speaker AThis was early 20th century doctors.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BBut it's still.
Speaker BSo.
Speaker BIt's just shocking how gruesome it is.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd I don't go in for the gruesome medical stuff.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BLike, even in.
Speaker BEven mild stuff.
Speaker BLike, we may talk about some this week with one of these shows.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BI don't.
Speaker BI don't mind, and I don't.
Speaker BI can't explain my brain here.
Speaker BViolence that results in something gruesome happening, that's one thing.
Speaker BBut if it is a medical procedure being shown not too close to home.
Speaker BThere were two.
Speaker BOne show that I really enjoyed.
Speaker BI.
Speaker BI feel like Millennials.
Speaker BIf you want to start subdividing us, let's do one sub generation.
Speaker BCould be the Scrubs generation.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BThat.
Speaker BThat show was a specific brand of humor and kind of got eclipsed by its contemporaries and then later the derivations of that.
Speaker BSo, like, the Office ends up being bigger and then Parks and Rec and Community, all the stuff.
Speaker BSo Scrubs is not remembered in the way that I assumed it would be at the time, but the kind of oddball humor stuck out at the time.
Speaker BAnd there was a.
Speaker BIt was more than just a setting.
Speaker BYou know, there was a medical component to it that they.
Speaker BThey leaned into some of the tropes occasionally, and I enjoyed that quite a bit.
Speaker BAnd I watched House when House was at its peak, just because it was a fun, like, potato chip kind of show.
Speaker AExactly.
Speaker AAnd I'm about roughly 10 years older than you.
Speaker AMaybe just a little more.
Speaker AActually.
Speaker AER was on my television all of my teenage years and into college era.
Speaker AIt was in that crucial Thursday night slot after Seinfeld.
Speaker ASo I bet you remember it pretty well, even as a young guy.
Speaker AAnd I can go way back and say General Hospital, which was a true soap opera in the middle of the day that my grandmother would watch.
Speaker AThat's what I've always associated medical dramas with.
Speaker ANot so much the medical, but the Drama, and I would even say melodrama are so soap opera.
Speaker ASo I've avoided it.
Speaker AI think for those reasons.
Speaker AI always took it as cheap as flippant.
Speaker AI do realize ER rose above the rest of broadcast TV at the time.
Speaker AI do acknowledge that.
Speaker AI think I was just too young to, to really watch it or sit still for a whole 45 minutes worth of it.
Speaker AIt just didn't cater to me as an early teenager.
Speaker AI was out doing other things, watching Seinfeld and then off to do whatever.
Speaker ABut I'm so glad I gave the pit a shot.
Speaker AThat's the show we're talking about here on Max.
Speaker AIt is fantastic.
Speaker AIt's not that melodramalodramatic at all.
Speaker AIt's just too fast to be dramatic.
Speaker AIt's well acted.
Speaker AThe story happens between characters as they're treating patients in this trauma center.
Speaker ASo what I mean by that is you have to be a careful watcher because you have to read into the looks they give one another.
Speaker AMaybe one doctor gives a nurse or a doctor gives another doctor.
Speaker AAnd it's not the usual oh, they're in love glance.
Speaker AIt's a glance that they have history.
Speaker AMaybe this guy doesn't trust another doctor for this or that reason and you just don't know yet.
Speaker AI'm only four episodes in.
Speaker AThere are eight that are streaming.
Speaker AIt's a weekly episode, which also appeals to me.
Speaker AWeekly series.
Speaker AAnd if you don't like a specific scene or story, don't worry.
Speaker AIt changes so suddenly.
Speaker AThe camera kind of follows a couple of doctors around and it is so fast that a curtain will open.
Speaker AThey'll go in, try to diagnose a patient, talk to that patient, give those glances you're to read into them, and then they're off to another patient as they close the curtain.
Speaker AAnd it's, it's at a neck break speed that fits our world quite well, but it also keeps you from being bored.
Speaker AAnd, and everything I've read about it is that it is the most realistic medical show that's, that's been on.
Speaker BHow gruesome is it?
Speaker AOh, there, there are two that come to mind right now, and I'm only four episodes deep in that.
Speaker AI mean, look, look away from the tv.
Speaker AGruesome.
Speaker ANoah Wy is the primary character, as I mentioned, he's just crushing it.
Speaker AI know he was on ER as Dr.
Speaker AJohn Carter, but there's no way he could have played that character.
Speaker AThis character then he's nearly grizzled.
Speaker ABut as Paul Simon said, he's soft in the center.
Speaker AAnd I could laud all of the actors, but he's the primary character and, man, he could carry a show.
Speaker AI'm ready to see him in anything now.
Speaker AI don't mention anyone else because most of them are actors who are.
Speaker AWho give you the oh, yeah, I've seen them vibe, but no names will come to mind.
Speaker AYou'll.
Speaker AYou'll use IMDb a lot and appreciate their style and what they bring.
Speaker AAnd here's the thing.
Speaker AThey could be on three episodes because they're in there for three hours, or they might be on one episode because they just got a stitch.
Speaker AIt's kind of a cool thing.
Speaker AI don't know.
Speaker AAnd I'm pray I'm talking about it.
Speaker AYou can tell I'm talking about it as a guy who's never watched medical dramas, because everybody else who's listening to this is probably saying, well, yeah, that's what they did on House, or that's what they did on er.
Speaker BI mean, Dave Matthews was on an episode of House.
Speaker ANo, he was not.
Speaker BHe was a patient.
Speaker AThat's so funny.
Speaker BThere's some trivia for you.
Speaker BIt does lend itself to, like you're saying, bringing.
Speaker BBringing folks in and out of frame.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYou want to use somebody just.
Speaker BIt's like a Seinfeld girlfriend.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BThey're not sticking around.
Speaker ABut then.
Speaker ABut here in this show, they could.
Speaker AThey could.
Speaker AThey could be in there for a trauma that lasts five episodes, and I think it's going to run about 12 or 15 episodes.
Speaker ALike it's an extended piece of television, too.
Speaker BJust.
Speaker BThat's rare these days.
Speaker AIt is rare.
Speaker AIt's got a more.
Speaker AIt's almost like it's blending everything you could possibly say that's good about broadcast along with HBO and melding the two, which is brilliant and why someone hasn't done it already.
Speaker AThis may be the most juvenile statement I've made about a show on this podcast, but I mean it when I assert that this show is about death way more than any shows are.
Speaker AThat maybe that we've covered.
Speaker AThat may be obvious is why I say it's juvenile, but maybe not.
Speaker AI think that series that predate the Pit, like Grey's Anatomy or er, are more interested in character interactions and relationships, whereas this one is about death.
Speaker AAnd I'm not talking about what's it like to die, what's in the great beyond, but no, the physical act of dying.
Speaker AIt is very interested in that.
Speaker BThe brutality of it.
Speaker AYes, thank you.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker AOr even just that it's not that brutal.
Speaker BYeah, that it's.
Speaker BIt's a thing that's happening every day.
Speaker BThat's interesting.
Speaker BI haven't thought about, you know, you mentioned Grey's Anatomy and shows like that being more about.
Speaker BI don't know, I've never watched a complete episode of Grey's Anatomy but it seems to be more about who's hooking up with who and that.
Speaker BYeah, that sort of thing.
Speaker BYeah, that kind of drama scrubs dealt with death and I mean there's a few very famous episodes that are very moving but they're more.
Speaker BWhat you're describing is like the emotional resonance if not what happens in the great beyond.
Speaker BLike how are the people here affected?
Speaker BHow are they sorting out their own feelings about mortality and what's important, these sorts of things versus just.
Speaker BYeah, that's.
Speaker BI can't think of the show that is just matter of fact about it there, ma'am.
Speaker AIt is very interesting.
Speaker ANot so much of what happens right after you die, but what happens right when you lead up to it.
Speaker AIt's.
Speaker AYeah, I think it's a really good show.
Speaker AIf anyone out there is watching it, let me know what you think.
Speaker AWhich is a nice segue for me.
Speaker AFor us to talk about the White Lotus in our non spoiler section.
Speaker AI love it when we get comments on our site or emails.
Speaker AOur pal Mr.
Speaker A87 Jetta floored me this week.
Speaker AHe said in an email that taking it down has been a weekly staple for me for over half a decade now.
Speaker ADang saying.
Speaker AAnd he says saying half a decade rather than five years makes it sound longer.
Speaker AHe says as a joke.
Speaker AAnd I thought, wow.
Speaker AI think the truth is we might have actually done this podcast a little longer than five years.
Speaker BWell, it's.
Speaker BIt's weird because it's.
Speaker BThe pandemic was just last year.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker B2022 is going to be wild when it comes next year.
Speaker AYeah, we started this podcast in 2018, summer.
Speaker BI think that sounds right.
Speaker AAnd he says five years.
Speaker ASo we've been a little longer than he had picked up on us.
Speaker ASo that's wonderful.
Speaker AThank you.
Speaker ABy the way, Mr.
Speaker AMr.
Speaker AJetta.
Speaker ASo white Lotus is where we're headed next.
Speaker ANon spoilers for to begin.
Speaker AJust, just in case anybody's wondering, what is this show?
Speaker AWhy is it by talking about it online.
Speaker AIt's an HBO anthology which resets every season.
Speaker ATells a tale as old as time.
Speaker ARich mostly white guests converge at a high class resort called the White Lotus and someone gets murdered.
Speaker AAin't that all vacations in it's funny.
Speaker BThat I just said I don't like the genre piece that a medical show usually provides, but usually when I say on this show, oh, it felt like a play.
Speaker BIt felt like a strong set piece with defined setting and, you know, characters running into each other.
Speaker BAnd I.
Speaker BThat's a positive thing.
Speaker BI usually love it.
Speaker BSo I realized the hypocrisy here.
Speaker BBut, yeah, I love the show.
Speaker BI love White Lotus.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BI think it's a genius setup.
Speaker BI can't remember if we talked about this on air or in text, but just.
Speaker BThey would have to do something profoundly disappointing for me to not continue watching.
Speaker BYeah, season one was great.
Speaker BSeason two was great.
Speaker BThe inertia and the intelligence of what they're doing, I feel like is going to carry them through for a long time.
Speaker BYou know, it's.
Speaker BAnd then I think of other anthologized shows like True Detective.
Speaker BSteep drop off for season two.
Speaker BI feel like this.
Speaker BThis knows what it's trying to do.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker AWell, we're gonna get into some of that a little.
Speaker AIt's.
Speaker AThe series, of course, is known for two things.
Speaker ABringing back a character from a previous season and starting with a mystery that shows us, like, the first bit of it, and then it'll back up a week or so to uncover how it all came to be.
Speaker AMike White is the writer and creator.
Speaker AAnd I always had to mention this every season because he wrote and I think maybe even had a hand in directing the ultimate Saturday afternoon movie, School.
Speaker BOf Rock, and is in.
Speaker AAnd he's in it.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker BNed Schneebly, he plays him.
Speaker BThis is.
Speaker BI always picture him in that movie.
Speaker BWhen I picture who's writing this and pulling the strings and doing.
Speaker BI mean, I know.
Speaker AIt's funny, isn't it?
Speaker B20 years has gone by since that's a juxtaposition between.
Speaker ABetween what you expect as a.
Speaker AFrom this writer and what he actually looks like.
Speaker AWhy.
Speaker AAnd his crew go into these seasons, they know their exact backstory for each of these characters, is my feeling, to the point that it's.
Speaker AI'd say this.
Speaker AIt's almost off putting.
Speaker ALike, well, I'm watching last week's episode, and I'm thinking, wait, am I supposed to know who this is?
Speaker AIs.
Speaker AYou know, there's a part of this story, I'm supposed to know what I miss.
Speaker AThe answer is usually no.
Speaker AHe just colors the pages way ahead of time, and you don't get to see what he's done until he's ready for you to, you know, to reveal.
Speaker BIt almost watches like reading Russian literature.
Speaker BI realize this is like a profoundly pretentious thing to say, but when you.
Speaker BNo, no, you read the.
Speaker BThe Russian greats and one.
Speaker BThere's like a million names for everybody.
Speaker BThat's tough, you know, so it's.
Speaker BIt's tough to feel you're like who's talking to who.
Speaker BAnd they're all usually presenting as well off and important and wealthy.
Speaker BBut that falls apart under closer inspection.
Speaker BA lot of the time I don't.
Speaker BIn the meeting of again, the meeting of characters in, you know, I think about like Dostoevsky riding like gamblers gathering at a casino.
Speaker BYou know, like they're not on their home turf yet.
Speaker BThey're in a space that they're comfortable with that society has given them.
Speaker BAnd the show.
Speaker BI mean, again, you said it at the top.
Speaker BIt's almost a cliche.
Speaker BRich people gather, things fall apart, you know.
Speaker BBut when you were saying that about the.
Speaker BYou just know that he has a real depth of knowledge for all of these characters going in and you're kind of just expected to.
Speaker BTo keep pace with him right from the word go.
Speaker BReminded me of.
Speaker BIt's a very literary show in that way to also be a very sexy show.
Speaker AOh yeah.
Speaker AIt hems closely to the Shakespearean definition of tragedy.
Speaker AYou gotta have somebody of importance who has this internal defect of character that causes shit to go down.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThe series does do a fine job of ensuring it's all revealed at once, but not at once.
Speaker AIt kind of doles out juicy tidbits of information and it does.
Speaker ASo unlike Shakespeare who will have a character just stand on stage and tell you everything.
Speaker AMaybe an act or two in.
Speaker AYou have to read it on their faces in some cases this season.
Speaker A3.
Speaker APretty heavy on the southern folk here.
Speaker AParker Cozy's laying it on thick as a southern belle.
Speaker AYeah, exactly.
Speaker AYou wonder.
Speaker AIt's an ugh thing.
Speaker AShe's a very rich mom from North Carolina and she of course is a Tar Heel because she keeps saying it.
Speaker AHer filthy rich husband is Mr.
Speaker ARatliff.
Speaker AHe graduated from Duke.
Speaker ATheir three kids carry the school rivalries to a point of contention.
Speaker AAnd though this episode hints at some darker things amongst this five, we can't say too much because we're non spoilers.
Speaker AMore southern flair with Walton Goggins character as Rick, also in Thailand.
Speaker AAnd you know, he's.
Speaker AHe's simmering in a place that's supposed to be known for relaxing you.
Speaker AAll we really know is that the White Lotus and its purpose of its first episode have you constantly determining what's their issue, what's that guy's problem, what's this lady's issue, what's their defect in.
Speaker BA more intense way than the first two seasons, I think.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd maybe they're playing with our expectations a little bit.
Speaker BYou know, when say season I assume we're in.
Speaker BIt's okay to spoil season one.
Speaker BYou're trying to kind of figure out who's good, who's bad, who's going to die.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker BAnd it's, it's the classic setup of we know someone we're going to encounter or someone has died and we're going to figure it out.
Speaker BThis one, you know, things eroded in that season and we're starting in a place this time where you immediately have more questions about every character, I think.
Speaker BYeah, if that makes sense.
Speaker AIt does.
Speaker AAnd you're.
Speaker AI think you're spot on.
Speaker AThey're playing with their own legacy.
Speaker AI love for shows to go week for week, but I'm not so certain that this particular season of Lotus couldn't have benefited from a two episode premiere.
Speaker AIt to me you're, you're talking about how they're.
Speaker AThey might be playing with their own history but it felt lacking to me than previous years.
Speaker AIt felt not as, not as propulsive.
Speaker AAlthough interesting.
Speaker AWhat, what am I speaking on there?
Speaker BI don't know if it's.
Speaker BAre you.
Speaker BDo you think you bring.
Speaker BYou know, the season one and two are like finished pieces in my mind.
Speaker BAre you bringing an expectation of it to do more in one episode?
Speaker AI can remember thinking about midway through this episode like where are you gonna color outside the lines of your template.
Speaker BAnd I think maybe there's a bit of, you know, season two had more familiar faces come back immediately continuity of storyline as well as Aubrey Plaza who's man pretty major star power immediately.
Speaker BAnd I mean there is star power in this one.
Speaker BThere you know, movie stars are in this but it.
Speaker BThat felt more.
Speaker BAnd again I joked about Subdivisions of Millennials earlier.
Speaker BIt seemed like she had a really good year last year career wise and this was like oh, this is part of her.
Speaker BOne of our own ascends back to the heights here.
Speaker ATough to compete against the sizzle between Aubrey Plaza and Theo James last season.
Speaker AA note for listeners as we approach the break that yep, as promised we're going to talk about SE and its sixth episode but since we discuss it episode by episode on a weekly basis I think we'll usually skip our general feel feelings about that Apple TV plus show.
Speaker BGo watch It.
Speaker BThere's my general feeling.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYou know, we're obviously on board because we're covering it.
Speaker AUsually if we drop something, we've lost some interest.
Speaker ASo we won't put much in non spoiler sections for recent episodes of Severance.
Speaker ASometimes we might, sometimes we won't.
Speaker AOkay, that takes us to our break.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AGive a listen here to a podcast you might enjoy.
Speaker ASome friends of ours for sports analysis and recaps that don't require yelling and will admit when they're wrong.
Speaker AIt's time for taking on sports.
Speaker ALook for taking on sports in any podcast app, part of the Alabama Take family of podcasts.
Speaker AOkay, we are now in spoiler section.
Speaker AFor those who need that reminder.
Speaker AWe'll kind of go in order.
Speaker AWe won't mention the pit here in spoiler section.
Speaker ASince only Adam.
Speaker AExcuse me.
Speaker ASince only I have watched it.
Speaker AI'm not sure if I sold Adam on the pit.
Speaker ADid I sell you on it?
Speaker BI don't know if I got the stomach for it.
Speaker AI look away on those scenes.
Speaker AMan.
Speaker BWe'll see.
Speaker AThe characters are so real.
Speaker AI just.
Speaker AI'm just curious what you would think.
Speaker ABut we are in the spoiler section.
Speaker AWe're gonna back up to the White Lotus and its first episode titled Same Spirits, Different Forms.
Speaker AIt's a kind of a fitting title.
Speaker ADirected by the creator Mike White, this season has monkeys all over the place.
Speaker AMy God, are the monkeys.
Speaker AYou know, I talked about at the very end of the spoil non spoiler section.
Speaker AI liked the episode, but I thought that because of the template it uses or may be playing with that this particular cast, or maybe it's the amount of time between seasons.
Speaker AIt's been two and a half years.
Speaker AI just did not feel as invested in this one as an opening episode as I have in the past.
Speaker AThat's not to say I won't be in love with it, you know, in two weeks.
Speaker BDidn't hook you.
Speaker ANot quite.
Speaker AAgain.
Speaker AIt's tough to compete against Aubrey Plaza and Theo James, a goofy grandfather who can't remember who's flirting with everyone because he can't remember anything.
Speaker BExactly.
Speaker AThat was last season.
Speaker AThis set of rich bastards all felt like they could have been in any season of the White Lotus.
Speaker AYou know, they got their first world problems, some more concerning than others.
Speaker AThis particular White Lotus cast group of people might be more into wellness, which is funny.
Speaker AThat's a kind of a trend these days.
Speaker AWellness.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BThat's yourself is.
Speaker BYou think that's part of it.
Speaker BPerhaps that didn't grab you as much that the first one.
Speaker BFirst season, we had no expectations.
Speaker BAnd it's these.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BBeautiful shots of Hawaii.
Speaker BSeason two, you've got some Italian glamour, I guess, and just jungle.
Speaker BWell, it's.
Speaker BIt's beautiful.
Speaker BIt is jungle.
Speaker BAnd it's.
Speaker BWe're going to meditate and put our phones in bags.
Speaker BAnd I'm into that as a viewer.
Speaker ASure, why not?
Speaker BAnd we were in spoilers here, right?
Speaker AYes, sir.
Speaker BThe intro to this one, the setup, I think this is the best one they've done.
Speaker ANow, that I agree with.
Speaker AThat was horrifying.
Speaker BYeah, that's what the word I was going to use was this.
Speaker BYou know, it makes season one seem tame.
Speaker AIt does.
Speaker BLike, the vague idea someone's going to die is kind of like a polite murder mystery dinner party set up versus a mass shooting event.
Speaker BI mean, this is.
Speaker AIt's almost like season one, you get the whispers of someone's gotten killed.
Speaker ASeason two, you get a gunshot or two.
Speaker AAnd then season three opens with what sounds like a mass shooting.
Speaker AAnd that is scary.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd to just follow one person in real time as they experience this and the juxtaposition of, you know, later in the episode, you find out this is the wellness hub for all of the white lotuses.
Speaker BThis is one of the premier places in the.
Speaker BIn the world.
Speaker BAnd you have who you figure out as Belinda's son there doing his meditation.
Speaker BHe doesn't want to recognize the gunshots.
Speaker BFinally he says, that's, you know, we have to move.
Speaker BAnd then just all hell breaks loose.
Speaker BSo there's a tension to the whole thing, you know, like with the shots of the security guards that are armed and things like that that you think, man, things.
Speaker BIt's not just going to be kind of chaotic, like maybe someone overdoses or maybe something, you know, there's a suicide or something like that.
Speaker BThere's going to be a violent event happening.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AHuh.
Speaker ABelinda's the return character, as is often part of the template.
Speaker AYou know, she's from the first season, and she sees that she isn't the only black lady at the upper crust resort, and she gives this big noticeable hello to the other black couple.
Speaker AAnd I was questioning, wait, should I know them?
Speaker ALike, they spent a lot of time having her say hello that it took me a minute to say, oh, she's just noticing she's the only lady of color.
Speaker AOr she's not the only lady of color.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BAs against they're playing all along with how she has to navigate a work world.
Speaker BLike, we all have a work Voice, you know, in a way of conducting ourselves.
Speaker BBut now she.
Speaker BWe see that break a bit when she sees the lizard for the first time on the.
Speaker BThat was hilarious.
Speaker BI almost wondered if they didn't tell the actress that that was going to be there because it seemed so well played by her.
Speaker AIt allowed for her Audi to come through.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BBut even when they show her where she's going to be staying while she's training and she realizes I'm living more like a guest than I am one of the staff.
Speaker BI thought that was.
Speaker BIt was fun to see someone who has to be sympathetic.
Speaker BThe most sympathetic character in season one, kind of have nice things happen to them.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAfter you see the bait and switch of being offered to fund a wellness center that then gets pulled away.
Speaker BAnd it's.
Speaker BYou kind of wonder how many times has this happened to her.
Speaker BThis is just something positive is going on in her life.
Speaker AHere you get these characters.
Speaker AYou're used to thinking, all right, what's their problem?
Speaker AI'll say this.
Speaker AAnd I think this is my major complaint.
Speaker AWhich will go away in a few weeks or should.
Speaker AThe opener worked too hard to get me involved in the intrigue and not as hard to get me involved with the characters.
Speaker AIt was too much mystery and not enough.
Speaker AHere's who this person is and why you should like or dislike or be interested.
Speaker BI think that's fair.
Speaker BAnd maybe the.
Speaker BThe drama of it is it's almost too much, too early.
Speaker AIt could be.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd then as you start meeting the characters, there is just not a lot of sympathetic energy.
Speaker AThat's my.
Speaker AAs well.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker APair that with them.
Speaker AWe get the Ratcliffe's first.
Speaker ALet's just talk about a few of these people.
Speaker AThey seem to be in trouble with some tax issues.
Speaker AInvestigation around such issues from the Wall Street Journal.
Speaker AThat's.
Speaker ANow they're the pure assholes of the season.
Speaker BBut they're not even.
Speaker BI mean, they have the.
Speaker BThe daughter Piper.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BWho.
Speaker BWho could be decent, seems decent and is interested in this.
Speaker BThis Buddhist temple down the road and.
Speaker BBut then you've got dad, who seems like a total asshole, and mom, who is so medicated that she falls asleep at the.
Speaker BThe public dinner table.
Speaker AMom likes the pills.
Speaker BShe's into the pills.
Speaker ANow Timothy, apparently is the patriarch.
Speaker AI think that's his name.
Speaker ADid he drop his Southern accent a few times?
Speaker BDo you think it was on purpose?
Speaker AI couldn't tell.
Speaker BTheir accents were.
Speaker BThis feels like a rare moment for us to just be complete experts on something.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThey're very Bad.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AParker Posey seems like she's a better actress than they said.
Speaker AI'm not so sure.
Speaker AShe's not from New Orleans or somewhere in the South.
Speaker AAtlanta.
Speaker BNo, I think she's just a New Yorker.
Speaker BRight?
Speaker AThat's a good question.
Speaker AShe should know better.
Speaker BBorn in Baltimore, so South.
Speaker AIsh.
Speaker ATD Wood would tell you that's the South.
Speaker BBut she.
Speaker BShe lived in Laurel, Mississippi, for a time.
Speaker AWell, that's very south.
Speaker BThat's pretty.
Speaker APretty south down there, almost along the coast.
Speaker AShe never quite loses hers, but it is so damn thick.
Speaker AIt's unrealistic or showy.
Speaker AYou know, it could be that she's always on the pills and she's just.
Speaker AThat's the way she sounds like.
Speaker AAnd then their three kids don't have one at all, which is.
Speaker AThat's a generational.
Speaker BThat's kind of believable.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BI thought that was of the things that they've done.
Speaker BThe fact, you know, taking her and comparing her to her daughter's way of speaking is.
Speaker BYeah, like you said, the generational idea of losing accent and trying to be more worldly and blah, blah, blah.
Speaker ADoes your accent thicken when you get around your grandparents?
Speaker BI don't think so, but I observed that happen in other people.
Speaker AMine does.
Speaker AWhen I used to get around my mom or dad or I'd be on the phone with them.
Speaker AIt was thick.
Speaker AAnother really disturbing moment.
Speaker AMaybe as much as the gunshots that opened the show.
Speaker AWas the Ratliff son sharing a bedroom and the older of the two, Saxon, does not hide his masturbatory exercises in front of his younger brother to the point that he hinted.
Speaker AOr he asks if he wants to join in.
Speaker BI mean, it's.
Speaker BDude, does he ask that?
Speaker AHe's like, what do you prefer?
Speaker AAnd he's pulling.
Speaker APulling it up as if to ready himself on his phone.
Speaker BI thought he was just making polite conversation.
Speaker ADo the monkeys symbolize incest?
Speaker ABecause I'm getting some big incest energy from older brother Saxon.
Speaker BEvery.
Speaker BEverything that he does is disturbing.
Speaker BAnd I mean, he seems like a sociopath.
Speaker BJust.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BI mean, he's maybe the.
Speaker AHe's commented on his sister's looks.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AI'm not so sure that Lachlan wasn't checking out older brother Saxon when he went to the bathroom to Andrea.
Speaker BThis is immediately.
Speaker BThe Internet says, well, the youngest brother is gay.
Speaker AThat's fair.
Speaker BHe gives a look to a guy.
Speaker BThe pool.
Speaker BApparently that I missed that people noted the less gross read on the bedroom bathroom interaction is him looking at his Brother, like, are you seriously doing this right now?
Speaker AThat's how I thought.
Speaker BThat's how I read it.
Speaker AAnd then I got to thinking about it more and I was like, well, older brother talks way too familiar about his sister being pretty good looking, should be having sex.
Speaker AAnd then younger brother looks.
Speaker AAnd I'm trying to piece it all together.
Speaker AIs that.
Speaker AIs that all of a piece.
Speaker AAre those separate things?
Speaker BWell, just.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BIn the immediate implication that he doesn't imply it, he just says it.
Speaker BYou shouldn't share a room with our sister.
Speaker BThat's not appropriate.
Speaker BWhy would that be inappropriate if something weird is going on?
Speaker BAnd the way that his mom reacts when he.
Speaker BWhat does he say something about.
Speaker BHe uses like, almost like a childlike term like genitals or something like that.
Speaker BAnd she says, you're not supposed to say that.
Speaker BAnd the way that she immediately puts her foot down on that in this, like, it's like they're in some sort of weird stuck in childhood kind of state.
Speaker AAnd the whole family seems like with the accent, like they're stuck in Civil war era kind of North Carolina.
Speaker BIt makes you ask pretty uncomfortable questions about like, why is mom drugging herself constantly?
Speaker BDid she.
Speaker BIs there some weird relationship between one of the parents and one of the kids?
Speaker BIs, you know, the sister trying to get younger brother to stay with her because she's the only sane one and trying to shield him in some way because she knows older brother is trouble?
Speaker AWell, if any of that's true, it is perfect that they went to UNC and Duke because that's the tobacco road.
Speaker AAnd if you've ever read Erskine Caldwell's Tobacco Road, that that vibe's prevalent in the novel.
Speaker BLove that they brought the Southerners on to bring the.
Speaker BThe incest.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AThanks a lot.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BMaybe you start with the idea of we want a.
Speaker BAn older brother to have the hots for his sister, and then you give him a southern accent after that.
Speaker BLike, that form just follows the function there.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ATo be fair, the kids don't have the accent.
Speaker AThere's a great shot of the three kids, though, where they're sitting on a.
Speaker AOn a bench and it mimics the See no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil of monkeys.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AContinuing to list sex Saxons more than.
Speaker AAnd you know, that name's so close to sex there.
Speaker AAnyway, more than gross issues.
Speaker AHe.
Speaker AHe pays way too much attention to his sister.
Speaker AAnd that is Arnold Schwarzenegger's son who plays.
Speaker AAnd he's pretty good at getting.
Speaker AUsing choices that convey creepy, spoiled, rich.
Speaker AHe 100% is a frat guy I've ran into in a college town.
Speaker BYeah, absolutely.
Speaker ASo well done there.
Speaker BI mean, he.
Speaker BAs I thought about episode one, again, he is the main thing that stuck with me.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BI don't love that.
Speaker AAnd that's saying a lot when you got Walton Goggins in the cast.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AWho's one of my favorite actors.
Speaker BMaybe you're not as into this one because season one we had Sydney Sweeney and Alexandria D'Addario and then Aubrey Plaza.
Speaker BAnd now this frat boy is what's stuck in your head.
Speaker BThis is quite the downgrade.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ALet's switch to Walton Goggins.
Speaker AI brought him up.
Speaker AHe plays Rick, and he sure was looking woefully at a picture of the lady who owns the place.
Speaker AFormer actress and what looked to be Scott Glenn in.
Speaker AIn a picture with her as probably her husband.
Speaker AYou have to think that's an estranged father situation.
Speaker BYou think it's an estranged father.
Speaker AWhat did you think?
Speaker AI went obvious.
Speaker AWhat do you think?
Speaker BHe kind of alludes to the fact that he can't go back to Australia.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AGoggins does.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ARick.
Speaker BThat perhaps there's a criminal element to whatever he's doing.
Speaker BMaybe he's looking to extort someone or.
Speaker BAll the way to the extreme end.
Speaker BHe could be a hitman of some sort.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWell, he's not.
Speaker AHe's not pleasant and chill.
Speaker ATo be there.
Speaker ABeing there is annoying him.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ASmoke in the Ratliff's face.
Speaker AHe's.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BWas kind of hilarious to watch because as that scene unfolded, this is.
Speaker BThis is good storytelling right off the bat.
Speaker BGreat acting.
Speaker BThat.
Speaker BHow did I end up sympathetic with the person smoking the cigarette?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYou know what I mean?
Speaker BLike, that person's never right in real life.
Speaker ANot.
Speaker ANot when they're blowing the smoke in the face.
Speaker ANo.
Speaker BRight, right, right.
Speaker BYou kind of clock the.
Speaker BThe Ratliff family and you're like, oh, yeah, I'm on the side of the guy blowing the smoke here, for sure.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AHe would be more of a fan of taking it down.
Speaker AHe's our audience.
Speaker AThe Rick guy would be more so than the Ratliffs.
Speaker ABut if that's Scott Glenn in the picture.
Speaker AI do think it is.
Speaker AThat makes two people straight from the set of Bad Monkey, because Michelle Monahan, she's the somewhat famous American actress on vacation with two childhood besties, she's also from Bad Monkey.
Speaker ATalk about some first world problems.
Speaker AThose two had to go from Key west for a set of a show to Thailand for their Jobs.
Speaker AI mean, brutal bra.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AMichelle Monaghan.
Speaker AI think it's Monaghan Monahan.
Speaker AHer character's Jacqueline, and she's an actress of some renown.
Speaker AAnd then the resort owner is a former actress there in Asia, there's this motif that White.
Speaker AMike White establishes she's pouring on some niceties to her buddy Kate and her other palace, Lori.
Speaker ALaurie's played by Carrie Coon, and she's like, you know, oh, I brought you here.
Speaker ADon't pay for anything.
Speaker AI'm treating you.
Speaker AAnd the other two are just seething at this idea that she's successful.
Speaker AThey all hate one another.
Speaker BThat's.
Speaker BThat's the immediate read on it, for sure.
Speaker BAnd then it kind of gets a little more nuanced when you realize that Carrie Coon's character, Laurie, is the odd man out in the whole thing.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd she's pissed.
Speaker BIs she pissed or does.
Speaker BThere's, like, a certain feeling of desperation and moments like that when she goes in her room and sees him and just, like, loudly yet quietly sobs.
Speaker AI don't know.
Speaker ABut everyone online feels like that's.
Speaker AThat's the relationships.
Speaker AThose are the relationships that will break apart at the seams and create the event.
Speaker AThat seems obvious.
Speaker AIt seems too obvious.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BGoggin's doing something crazy.
Speaker BFeels.
Speaker BI mean, there's.
Speaker BChekov has a gun strapped to both of those security guards, you know.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYou know the other thing that could happen, A monkey could get hold of one of those guys.
Speaker BDudes.
Speaker AThat was my thought.
Speaker AThe other motif is the monkeys.
Speaker AWhat are the odds that the gunshots were just monkeys who've had enough?
Speaker BOh, they got organized.
Speaker AThey're viewing.
Speaker AYou know, we don't get Tanya and the gays trying to kill her, but she died anyway.
Speaker ABut we do get her husband, ex husband, whatever he is now widower Greg.
Speaker AThere he is.
Speaker AAnd he's got a new young girlfriend.
Speaker AApparently it's a thing for this resort or even Thailand itself, to have bald men with hot young girlfriends to the point they have a nickname for them.
Speaker AI'm not good with remembering things with the White Lotus because of the stretch it takes to film these.
Speaker ABut Greg was never fully shown to be active in trying to get Tanya killed.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AIt was just heavily alluded to.
Speaker AHeavily granted.
Speaker BImplied.
Speaker BAnd you.
Speaker BYou never know if he meets her in season one and it's a crime of opportunity or if the whole thing was orchestrated in some way.
Speaker ABut he's living off her cash, isn't he?
Speaker ARight now seems to be doing pretty.
Speaker BWell because they're not staying at the White Lotus.
Speaker BThey live or have an extended stay up the hill, right?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd Belinda's gonna recognize him.
Speaker AShe knows him well.
Speaker BThat's been discussed online this week.
Speaker BThis.
Speaker BThis person that she.
Speaker BDid they meet in season one beyond, like a.
Speaker BAn interaction that she would have had with guests a hundred times a week.
Speaker ABut she worked for Tanya.
Speaker BDid that relationship extend beyond season one?
Speaker AThat's a good question.
Speaker AIt's one for the Internet.
Speaker BIt does seem like that they're on a crash course to recognizing each other and to maybe questions being asked.
Speaker BWe would think that Belinda would have knowledge of what happened in Italy.
Speaker BHow this resort has continued to convince people to come visit based on its.
Speaker AHow's the Better Business Bureau not been brought in on a White Lotus?
Speaker BWell, they're clearly not researching because they, you know, TripAdvisor did not convince the Ratliffs or tell them, you know, he brags about, I find all the best spots and they try to take their cell phones and it does not go well.
Speaker AGreg's appearance makes him look a lot more haggard than he seemed the last time we saw him.
Speaker AHe's.
Speaker AIs he missing that cowboy hat just a little too much, or is he dying?
Speaker AIn Italy, we saw a picture of young Greg, cowboy hat and all.
Speaker BOne read is he could have actually been sick and that what he says is going on.
Speaker AHe does say that.
Speaker AAnd he coughs a lot.
Speaker AAnd then his cough kind of goes away.
Speaker BTwo would be that he has been avoiding law enforcement in some way for some months.
Speaker AHey, he works for the.
Speaker AFor the Bureau of Land Management.
Speaker AThank you very much.
Speaker BMaybe he's been let go.
Speaker BElon fired him and he went to.
Speaker BWent to Thailand.
Speaker AI can't help but look at him and think he's gonna try to throw a football over a mountain.
Speaker BYou think that's coming from Napoleon?
Speaker AHis role in Napoleon?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AWell, speaking of monkeys who've had enough, we'll discuss the sixth episode of Severance titled Attila.
Speaker AIf I may, I'll start with an email.
Speaker AWe got an email in and I think, what, two emails this week?
Speaker ASomething like that.
Speaker ASecond week in a row we've had either two comments or two emails or both.
Speaker BThis one's from Ben Stiller.
Speaker AThis one's from Ben Stiller.
Speaker AWe must be doing something right.
Speaker AThen again, emails sometimes can.
Speaker BYou can turn that caps lock off.
Speaker BBen.
Speaker AThis is actually from Tim Hamilton, one of our friends from SETI Bimco podcast.
Speaker AHe writes.
Speaker AEnjoyed your talk about severance, episode five.
Speaker ASo he's Going to be addressing something that you weren't here for, Adam.
Speaker ASo we'll blame Donovan.
Speaker BOkay, that sounds great, he says, but.
Speaker AI was talking aloud to the computer that you didn't talk too much about how Mark having sex with Haley.
Speaker ANot any.
Speaker ANot realizing she was Audi Heli would really mess with his head.
Speaker AIt was Irving who figured it out after all.
Speaker AIf this happened to me, I feel it may shatter my self image and my confidence in my own intelligence.
Speaker ADoes he like Audi Heli better?
Speaker AMark's our avatar, maybe our hero for this first season.
Speaker ABut now I feel like Irving, Heli and Dylan are more so I like Mark a little less and less.
Speaker AWell, Mark turned out to be a baddie.
Speaker APlus you didn't mention the last line in episode five.
Speaker AThat line suggests Mark's Audi could kill someone.
Speaker BI cannot believe that Donovan neglected his duties to such a degree that this email.
Speaker AOh, I forget so much week to week.
Speaker AI'm so happy.
Speaker AHappy listeners are patient with us.
Speaker BBut yeah, those are not gonna happen on my watch.
Speaker AWell, I appreciate the email because that those are excellent points and I do like to use them here in our podcast.
Speaker ABut I don't know that Mark will.
Speaker AWill become an antagonist.
Speaker AThat just.
Speaker AIt feels as though Lumen itself has that very well handled.
Speaker AWill he become a tool of Lumen?
Speaker AI don't think so.
Speaker ABut there's other ways to become a bad for the show.
Speaker BI think that those.
Speaker BThat was a pretty prescient email to come before this week.
Speaker AYeah, we can go right into this week because we're in spoiler section.
Speaker ASo what do you think?
Speaker BThat was one of the central action points, right?
Speaker BThat Mark and Helly figuring out how that has affected them.
Speaker BYou know, he finally admits what happened.
Speaker BBut you also see Audi Mark not behaving in like the most stand up way or the most consistent way with how he has behaved in the past.
Speaker BYou know, he's kind of a jerk.
Speaker ATo his sister, but he was under duress.
Speaker BHe was under duress, but he created.
Speaker BHere's someone who wants to help him and he's keeping her at arm's length and kind of acting impulsively.
Speaker BAnd I think you see more darkness in him than has been shown so far.
Speaker BYou know, season one, it establishes this is a depressed widower.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BBut I think there could be more to it.
Speaker BAnd it made me think of another Apple show shrinking, where you're kind of wondering all along, you know, there's been a driving accident of some sort, who's responsible for what here.
Speaker AI feel like Mark's darkness, especially in this episode, is just brought upon by his circumstances.
Speaker AIt's not so much that he's going to become some worse version of himself.
Speaker AI mean, he could, but it's because of going through this process and it's just not.
Speaker AYeah, he's scared that he could die at any minute because that's what happened to Petey.
Speaker BI think that there.
Speaker BThere's.
Speaker BThere's folks making all kinds of theory posts and videos out there, and one that I saw, you know, they're also playing with, with Bert and Irving, the idea of resets.
Speaker BAnd this is something that Helena also threatens Coble with.
Speaker BMaybe we need a reset.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BEarly this season.
Speaker BIs it possible?
Speaker BBecause they can clearly control brains if you're at Lumen or not.
Speaker BBased on the overtime contingency, could they possibly be screwing with the Audis as well in some way?
Speaker AI think so.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AI would think so.
Speaker BWhen they have the con.
Speaker BI know we're really flying all over the place here.
Speaker BWhen Helena confronts Mark at the Chinese restaurant.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker BI feel like there's this.
Speaker BA series of very intentional things that she says.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BLike saying Hannah as a mistake.
Speaker BHe corrects her to.
Speaker BThese are all things that they're gauging.
Speaker BYou have to assume that she knows everything.
Speaker AHuh.
Speaker BAnd that she's testing him as far as reactions go to all of this.
Speaker AShe was to see if he was.
Speaker AHas changed any.
Speaker AIf he has been able to become his any.
Speaker ASo by saying Hannah to his Audi, that's a test, right?
Speaker BWell, who is Hannah?
Speaker AIt's a test for her to.
Speaker AFor him to correct her.
Speaker ATo say Gemma.
Speaker AAm I wrong about that?
Speaker BI think that maybe, you know, some people have said, was his wife pregnant when she died?
Speaker BWould Hannah have been.
Speaker BAnd Helena even says so young.
Speaker BYou know, she means a.
Speaker BAn adult who was still youngish.
Speaker BOr she could have meant maybe an unborn child that they were going to name Hannah or something along those lines.
Speaker BI mean, obviously the show is set up to where you can read in a thousand details like that, but it.
Speaker AAlso tends to answer within a week or two.
Speaker AIt doesn't.
Speaker AIt allows you to speculate, but it doesn't elongate that speculation process.
Speaker BIt.
Speaker BIt does also do such a good job of burrowing in on what should be simple ideas.
Speaker BI mean, the whole premise of the show is that you were split in half and one half goes to work and one half lives on the outside.
Speaker BSo we've had years at this point to make peace with this idea, yet they're still Milking that for new emotional terrain.
Speaker AYeah, they're doing great.
Speaker BThis episode was all about that.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BLike how many times did the Burton Irving find each other on the severed floor where they both reset at times?
Speaker BDo they pos.
Speaker BIf they can control Audis too, Do they have some history there?
Speaker BDylan is shown again him and his wife.
Speaker BAny.
Speaker BDylan has more chemistry with his wife than his Audi self.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd now you have Mark flashing back and forth.
Speaker BHeli to me is the only one when she is fully heli who is not.
Speaker BYou don't question her.
Speaker BYou know, I don't think you do with Dylan either.
Speaker BYou're just.
Speaker BYou're haunted by the idea of like this is the best version of this guy.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AIn a sad way.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BHelly is completely her.
Speaker BAnd she had.
Speaker BWe joked early.
Speaker BNot joked, but said, you know what happens if you come in with a hangover?
Speaker BAnd then it got a little more serious before they.
Speaker BBefore the sexual encounter.
Speaker BWhat happens if somebody's pregnant?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BAnd you're just suddenly.
Speaker BYou know.
Speaker AWhich is why they would want to control as much as they can outside as well.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BBut she has a great little rapid fire of dialogue about how much she hates her outy self for getting up every morning and dressing me like I'm a doll and sending me in here.
Speaker BDo you remember that?
Speaker AWhen did she say that?
Speaker BIt was early on in the episode.
Speaker BShe's talking to Mark.
Speaker ANo.
Speaker BJust how much she resents this woman that he slept with.
Speaker AWell, okay, let's.
Speaker ALet's back up and cover some of these in depth.
Speaker AYet Mark finally does admit to sleeping with who he thought was heli.
Speaker AHe says this to Haley and Britt.
Speaker ALauer moves from acting that shows disappointment that it's not her to creep out to jealousy to pure eyes anger.
Speaker AAnd that all happens in a nice four seconds.
Speaker AThere is.
Speaker AIs it before that that she mentions I'm so pissed at being dressed like a doll.
Speaker BIt's either then or.
Speaker BAnd I should have.
Speaker BI should have pulled notes for this.
Speaker BBut when she's.
Speaker BShe's walked around and comes back to talk to.
Speaker BTo Mark again.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BHe's decided he's going to go find her and she's also coming to find him.
Speaker BAnd they almost run into her.
Speaker AShe walked away and then took off her shoes and then sat down.
Speaker ABut the whole shoe thing, I don't know.
Speaker AIt was very.
Speaker AI want to put that in there if you don't have to.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BI don't know.
Speaker BI don't have to read on the shoes.
Speaker AMe either.
Speaker AWe get the return of Dylan's wife Gretchen for a visit.
Speaker AAnd I failed to mention how great an actor Merritt Weaver is back in her first appearance this season.
Speaker AGlad Riders brought her back.
Speaker ASo many opportunities for just endless fascinations between the two and she's very much more in love with any Dylan than any other version of her husband.
Speaker AAnd he's smitten too and.
Speaker ABut she feels a lot of guilt for that.
Speaker BIt also brings up the idea that for Dylan specifically, you know, there, there is no.
Speaker BThis sounds brutal to say about somebody who has a family at home, but it's just as much that his Audi is working s as any.
Speaker BAnd I think maybe he's suffering more than any of the other ones because he shows up, seems to pass his wife as she goes out the door for a night shift, is responsible for kids all night long, but has no sense of, you know, he's very good at that job.
Speaker BBut his Audi self gets none of the satisfaction of that, none of the pride in work.
Speaker BAnd so all he does is pass his wife at the door, take care of kids, goes in, doesn't remember a thing, comes home and does it again.
Speaker BSo his, the monotony of that home life is, you know, not a bad thing if you were also getting purpose somewhere else.
Speaker BYeah, I guess that's the point they're trying to make.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AThe show loves to pair things.
Speaker AIt loves pairs.
Speaker AThis week it paired kisses and it had a hint that it won't end well for one of the Dylan's.
Speaker AI suspect his Audi back on the couch is the one that's going to get the end of the stick.
Speaker ABut we get the kisses being paired.
Speaker AIt's, it's Dylan and his real wife of course, but it's his any kissing her and then Mark and Hadley kiss and then go on to have sex one more time.
Speaker BWhich makes you wonder who the.
Speaker BWhat circumstance is going to produce the child that we all think is going to.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BBe born.
Speaker AYou know, it's worth noting that Gretchen lies about not seeing any Dylan.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker ADue to a cancellation.
Speaker BShe lies about that's again for them to have this idea for so long to be presented with the severed concept and still finding ways to make me go, man, that is heartbreaking that, you know, here's somebody who a bit beat down by life and all of a sudden you find and get to spend time with like a youthful, less jaded version of the person you fell in love with.
Speaker AYeah, yeah, man, that's so cruel.
Speaker BIt's cruel to everyone involved.
Speaker AI talked A few weeks ago about how I find it hard to swallow or wrap my head around the characters not feeling some semblance of connection to their Audi or any.
Speaker ABut here heli.
Speaker AWell, Brit Lauer I suppose sold it to me.
Speaker AShe.
Speaker AShe paints this stark image of an innie and Audi being vastly different to the point of being another person when she, she got pissed off at her Audi.
Speaker ALike I wanted to be the one to sleep with Mark, to kiss Mark, whatever it was.
Speaker AAnd I'll say that their sexual encounter felt.
Speaker AFelt less like a tent, more like the plastic they use for dead bodies.
Speaker AIt was not to continually return to Twin Peaks, but that plastic wrapped in.
Speaker BPlastic, founder wrapped in plastic.
Speaker BIt's.
Speaker BIt was definitely a contrast to a fire lit tent.
Speaker BWell, everybody all warmed up and yeah, that was.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ANot as sexy.
Speaker BA far cry from that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AI have a question for you.
Speaker AYou feel as though you've eradicated from yourself your childish follies.
Speaker BThat was a great scene.
Speaker AI loved it.
Speaker BI mean he, Milchick goes into that room to work on his evaluation stuff.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BLike he's putting paperclips on repeatedly.
Speaker AHe eliminates reps in to do it.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BEliminates the fancy words somebody had rightfully pointed out.
Speaker BYou know I don't think the Ennis are the ones informing on him.
Speaker BYou know Mark doesn't tell the board.
Speaker BOh he didn't understand all the words that he said.
Speaker BIt's Ms.
Speaker BWong that's telling him.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BYou know all of this stuff.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker ADonovan and I speculated as much that it's her.
Speaker AShe's really ratting him.
Speaker BYeah, yeah.
Speaker AOh yeah.
Speaker AI thought that it was fascinating that he is demanding to the man in the mirror.
Speaker AThere's that duality again to grow up.
Speaker AYet he's reverting to simple phrases.
Speaker AHe's reverting to more.
Speaker AMore childlike or easier to understand things.
Speaker BBecause they're playing a lot this season with showing us just how childlike the Enies are.
Speaker AThat's right.
Speaker BSomeone astutely pointed out.
Speaker BAnd when I say someone in these, I don't mean a reviewer, I mean somebody on Reddit that I as I come through they said it's really clever to have this teenage girl watching over these adults who are actually children to drive home, you know, who do you hire to babysit your kids?
Speaker BWhat's the old trope?
Speaker BYou Some, some high school girl.
Speaker A16 year old high school girl.
Speaker AThat's right.
Speaker BThat's who's watching the kids.
Speaker AThere you go.
Speaker ASpeaking of Bert and Irv Giving them a visit.
Speaker AFields is Bert's husband, and he calls Bert Attila.
Speaker AThat's the title.
Speaker ABut they say they got that from calling one another hun.
Speaker AYou know, it evolved into that.
Speaker AField says it came after meeting a severed partner of Birch 20 years ago.
Speaker ABut Irv is quick to point out that the first severed office didn't open until 12 years ago.
Speaker AOr it was 12 years ago.
Speaker ASo the timeline there is different.
Speaker AAnd Bert unsuccessfully shuts down Fields from.
Speaker AFrom drinking.
Speaker AFields unabashedly questions if they've had sex, unprotected sex, and even says, any should have love, they should have this going on.
Speaker AAlmost impressive.
Speaker BHe talked about it with his pastor.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ASo weird.
Speaker BThis was the Christian.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker ABird makes the first mention of any religion on this show that I'm aware of on how he got to Lumen.
Speaker AHe split himself so he could have a better chance, or one of his selves would have a better chance to go to heaven.
Speaker AAnd I've been playing with the idea that this is reminiscent of Scientology, but yet here's a real mention in the show of religion.
Speaker BIt makes it feel even more dystopian that his pastor would be forced to have an opinion on such a thing.
Speaker BYou know, to accept as reality that human beings may have been able to split a soul in some way.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ADo they.
Speaker AWhen you split your consciousness like that, does it split your soul?
Speaker BI still don't know if you can take anything said at that dinner at face value.
Speaker BWhen they make Bert out to be that he is, he has done such bad things that he needs to hedge his bets by splitting his soul and creating a more childlike version of himself to act right in a, you know, contained environment.
Speaker BIt's a fun look at nature, nurture.
Speaker BIf you.
Speaker BWhatever you are, whatever that every religion has a different way of understanding the you.
Speaker BYour consciousness is split and put into a non worldly place in a way, a place that's hyper structured.
Speaker BWould you thrive there versus whatever he's done going through the temptations of a fallen world.
Speaker BIf he has this Christian worldview and a Lumen worldview.
Speaker BYou know, it's odd that somebody that they have basically turned Lumen into religion, that somebody who is so deeply in their church world would be what seems to be like a foundational part of the Lumen process.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BHe's clearly got more to do with severing than he's letting on.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AThat's.
Speaker AThat seems the case.
Speaker AAnd I wouldn't be surprised if Bert was falsifying his interest in chemistry With Irv, because I think his name's Drummond.
Speaker AHe was in somebody somewhere, as you know, Iceland.
Speaker AThe big guy, he's in Irv's house snooping around.
Speaker AWe don't see him break in.
Speaker AWe just get the very quick look at him looking through some files that we knows in Irv's house.
Speaker ASo did Burt.
Speaker AHe was watching him.
Speaker ADid he lure him?
Speaker ADid he invite him?
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BGet him out of the house.
Speaker AGet him out of the house.
Speaker AGo get him out.
Speaker AWell, we'll definitely find out, I suppose.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BI just.
Speaker BI don't know that you can believe anything that was right said at that dinner.
Speaker BIt all.
Speaker BIt felt weird all along.
Speaker BAnd even the way that it was lit, you know.
Speaker AYes.
Speaker BBert has a very like evil emperor kind of look behind him the whole time.
Speaker BIt's very dark, black behind him.
Speaker ADiscussing heaven and hell in front of the fireplace.
Speaker AThere's that image.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BWell.
Speaker BAnd we know that Irv has been reset Right.
Speaker BAt work, that he used to work in other departments but has no memory of it.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker BIs it possible that him and Bert had.
Speaker BYeah, yeah.
Speaker BThat idea of would, you know, if Mark and Helly were just two severed co workers and it wasn't the person who's running the company, if they bumped into each other on the street, would there be some spark?
Speaker BYou know, does our consciousness carry over?
Speaker BAnd they kind of seem to indicate that it might at that Chinese restaurant.
Speaker BEven though they're having this pretty.
Speaker BBecomes a pretty intense conversation.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BWhere they're kind of fact finding on each other.
Speaker ABefore we move on from Irv, I.
Speaker BWill say I want to.
Speaker BI do want to circle back to that.
Speaker AOkay, go ahead.
Speaker BI'm getting to that.
Speaker BThey still have this moment of kind of joking around and like easy chemistry with each other that's kind of undeniable.
Speaker AEven though they being Irv and Bert.
Speaker BThey being Helena and Mark at the Chinese restaurant.
Speaker BBut then to support the idea that maybe Bert and Irv fell in love multiple times on the severed floor and were re set in some way and that Fields knows this.
Speaker AHuh.
Speaker BAgain, it's.
Speaker BIt's like a.
Speaker BA mirror to Dylan and his wife's situation.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BHow do you.
Speaker BHow do you deal if this person keeps finding this guy?
Speaker AHuh.
Speaker BIn this world that you don't have access to, what do you make of that as this person's partner?
Speaker AKind of a little comment on soulmate or something.
Speaker BRight?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ABritt Lauer.
Speaker AThis was her episode, if you ask me.
Speaker AWhen she does follow Mark to the Chinese restaurant or appears there she presents herself as this affable, flirtatious boss and not a steely head of lumen as we've seen her in all these other meetings.
Speaker AOf course, she it up by calling Jim a Hannah.
Speaker ANow, is that a purposeful fuck up?
Speaker AIf so, it could be.
Speaker ATo check on, is this truly his Audi?
Speaker AHas he changed?
Speaker AIs he doing something at home?
Speaker AGreat dichotomy too, that the set for the Chinese restaurant is so much in blatant contrast with the office spaces.
Speaker AIt's so dark in there, you almost had to lean in to see what was going on.
Speaker AAnd usually when they share a frame, it's just white and, you know, so bright on the screen.
Speaker AAnd then you get the Chinese restaurant there and it rattles Mark enough that he wants to go whole hog at home with this lady.
Speaker AAnd I never remember her name, but I don't think she's a medical professional.
Speaker ABefore it's over, Mark's on the floor and he, you know, I'm no doctor either, but he looks bad.
Speaker BSomething, something is not going well.
Speaker AAnd that's when his sister comes in.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnd we talked about how he's, he's, he's really kind of mean to her, but he's also going through some shit in that.
Speaker BBut he's moment he's.
Speaker BTo me, he's been mean to her by excluding her from this.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BThis is the one person in the world that you get the sense that they are very close for, even for siblings, you know, maybe that they're.
Speaker BSome people have inferred some trauma bonding maybe from their childhood that they are protective of each other.
Speaker AAre they twins?
Speaker ANow that would be funny.
Speaker BAnother idea of splitting.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AAnother compliment of the show.
Speaker BBut to exclude this person who is the only one who's consistently had your best interest at heart.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BI mean, people in trying circumstances and not trying circumstances drive people away who are close to them, but obviously he's going through it and this would be part of it, but it's still like, come on, man, she wants to help.
Speaker AUnless we hear something else that it's probably just a matter of.
Speaker AShe wouldn't let me do this.
Speaker AShe would probably physically get involved and hold me, you know, restrain me and I wouldn't want to do this.
Speaker BHe knows that he's, he's gone with this idea.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AWell, we'll end here and we'll also remind you that if you enjoyed this podcast, why not leave a comment on the home side of the Alabama take?
Speaker AThere's a place for comments at the bottom.
Speaker AReal easy.
Speaker AWe read them.
Speaker AWe read them on air.
Speaker AOr you can send an email to the alabamatakemail.com I know that's not taking it down, but that's our home site.
Speaker AWe everything gets bundled up into that.
Speaker AYou can always leave a review in your podcast app for taking it down.
Speaker ADo all three.
Speaker ABoy howdy.
Speaker AThat would be a great week for Adam and for Donovan, who will be back with us next week.
Speaker AThis was a lot of fun.
Speaker AWe hope you enjoyed it and we'll talk to you next week.